For unsafe Rust code to be sound, it has to uphold the invariant that no location pointed to by an &mut is modified through a pointer not derived from that &mut. However, there's no such restriction on *mut pointers ("raw pointers"), and it is in many cases perfectly sound (but unsafe, of course) to cast from *mut to &mut, or to directly mutate through a *mut. Without maintaining global information about what references are live, it sounds really, really hard to guarantee this.
It's still useful for making swapping work efficiently, but that's not relevant on a tiny embedded device.
Fil-C just says that shared memory mappings are integer-only, so trying to place a capability there instantly traps. That’s both sound and adequate even for sophisticated uses of shared memory.
My understanding is that this is a conundrum for CHERI, but maybe my understanding is wrong.
No virtual memory is not an advantage of CHERI, it’s a disadvantage. It means CHERI replaces a very well understood security barrier (virtual memory) with one that is less well understood (no matter how many proofs you write about it). I would be more willing to buy CHERI’s claims if they had kept virtual memory. Fil-C plays nice with virtual memory so there’s no need to disable it.