News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Future of TLA+ [pdf] by Certhas on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @04:23PM (#41383894)
Simple =/= easy.

It seems to me that TLA+ is executable in the sense that a difference equation can be run forward in time. Plenty of mathematics is executable in that sense.

Specification is not the same thing as implementation. A specification language does not tell a machine what operations to perform, a programming language does.

System behavior and systems programming are entirely different uses of the word system.

Re:The Future of TLA+ [pdf] by Mathnerd314 on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @08:50PM (#41386103)
TLA+ is executable in the sense of Prolog: there is an algorithm (the TLA+ implementation) that takes a TLA+ program and produces output. Most mathematics is not executable in this sense, you will have a very difficult time doing anything useful with the PDF's of published math papers. Math is a natural language, TLA+ is not.

And I would agree, TLA+ as a specification is different from TLA+ as an implementation. I generally disregard specs, I was talking about TLA+ the implementation when I said it had no future. It seems it will be in perpetual maintenance mode with barely any new features.

Regarding simple vs. easy, I challenge you to argue that temporal logic is "simple" in any sense of the word.

Re:The Future of TLA+ [pdf] by erichocean on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @09:46PM (#41386436)
> Math is a natural language

Almost spit out my drink dude, no jokes this early in the day.

Re:The Future of TLA+ [pdf] by Mathnerd314 on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @11:52PM (#41387110)
ChatGPT does just fine with math. I wasn't joking...
Re:The Future of TLA+ [pdf] by pistoleer on Thursday August 29, 2024 @04:39AM (#41388651)
What's the joke?
Re:The Future of TLA+ [pdf] by epgui on Thursday August 29, 2024 @04:39PM (#41395025)
If you really take the time to carefully think it through... Math is a much more "natural" and "intuitive" language than nearly any programming language.

That doesn't mean that it's easy, or easier, or that it feels more familiar to a programmer. These are different things.

Re:The Future of TLA+ [pdf] by epgui on Thursday August 29, 2024 @04:19PM (#41394873)
While I agree with you on the general idea, I think this is too restrictive:

> A specification language does not tell a machine what operations to perform, a programming language does.

There is a style of programming (usually functional or relational programming) that does not bother itself with operations, and which aims to merely describe a result. Specifications are still different from implementations written in such a style of programming.