Re:Experiment: Unit testing isn't enough; You need static ty...
by AngryParsley on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @11:01AM
(#4137300)
I would feel bad editing my comment now that you've replied, but my original intent was to say that type-checking is "free." At some point the quotes were lost.
To get as close to the land-mine as I am willing: I like C. I like Python. I like Ruby. But most of all, I like using the right tool for the job.
Re:Experiment: Unit testing isn't enough; You need static ty...
by Peaker on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @12:11PM
(#4137621)
I am not claiming static typing is free.
But it is also untrue that you have to "add declarations and type casts". With type inference, you don't actually have to.
Re:Experiment: Unit testing isn't enough; You need static ty...
by Goladus on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @12:17PM
(#4137653)
But you have to use a language with type inference. That's still a cost. Maybe not a big one, but that was my point (and I'm definitely nitpicking a bit, I realize that.)
Re:Experiment: Unit testing isn't enough; You need static ty...
by dllthomas on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @01:52PM
(#4138162)
A constraint is only possibly a cost - if it forces behavior you wouldn't have chosen otherwise.
Re:Experiment: Unit testing isn't enough; You need static ty...
by Goladus on Wednesday June 20, 2012 @02:39PM
(#4138438)
True, but free usually means freedom from both cost and restraint, so the point doesn't change much. I should have said "constraint" rather than "cost".
Though the original commenter did follow-up, clarifying that the common interpretation of "free" doesn't closely match the point he'd intended to make
If you claim type-checking is free, the counter-argument is not that it "slows development." The counter is that type-checking is not free because it incurs measurable costs. You may sacrifice dynamic features, you may have to add declarations and type casts-- these are all costs whether they "slow development" or not.
(Simple solution: don't waste time trying to claim type-checking is free and just focus on the benefits.)