Re:Intel SGX Fuse Key0, a.k.a. Root Provisioning Key Was Ext...
by chc4 on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:47PM
(#41362565)
I'm under the impression enclave keys have been extracted before, and Intel was able to mitigate by essentially publishing a key revocation update that made models with the extracted keys not be trusted for remote attestation. Is that also the case with these keys?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Intel SGX Fuse Key0, a.k.a. Root Provisioning Key Was Ext...
by fallingsquirrel on Monday August 26, 2024 @06:24PM
(#41362836)
That doesn't solve the greater issue. Let's say you bought an Intel CPU because your company requires remote attestation. Then a researcher publishes an exploit. Then Intel pushes an update that revokes keys from your model of CPU. What would you do, go happily spend $500 on a new one? Should we landfill millions of CPUs everytime the mouse pulls ahead of the cat?
Re:Intel SGX Fuse Key0, a.k.a. Root Provisioning Key Was Ext...
by throwaway2037 on Monday August 26, 2024 @08:48PM
(#41363648)
I disagree. This seems like fantasy. First, I don't think Intel has even done this -- "pushes an update that revokes keys from your model of CPU". If they did, there would be an enormous class action lawsuit. Remember that most CPUs are bought by large corporations, with extremely deep pockets. Even if Intel were to miraculously win the case, surely their reputation would irreparably harmed.
Re:Intel SGX Fuse Key0, a.k.a. Root Provisioning Key Was Ext...
by hsbauauvhabzb on Monday August 26, 2024 @11:05PM
(#41364247)
If that were the case, spectre, meltdown and similar vulnerabilities would surely have similar class actions?
Re:Intel SGX Fuse Key0, a.k.a. Root Provisioning Key Was Ext...
by Mindwipe on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @11:10AM
(#41368430)
This is pretty common FWIW.
Google revokes attestation keys for Android hardware a lot, especially Widevine Level 1 keys.
Ten years into that, the public doesn't seem very excised about it.
Re:Intel SGX Fuse Key0, a.k.a. Root Provisioning Key Was Ext...
by dogma1138 on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @05:31AM
(#41365789)
IIRC this is the first time a fused key was leaked; keys were leaked before but those were firmware keys which were encrypted with the root fused key which as it’s name suggests is literally fused into the silicon through programmable fuses.
It’s unclear if Intel has enough fuses to push a new key and if there is a mechanism to do it in software without a specialized programming station.
If the latter two are possible and they can fix the leak vector with a ucode update then they can likely revoke the key and patch this over.