I unfortunately spent the entire introduction to calculus in hospital, so missed it - when I came back to school, I was dropped straight into “differentiate this” and “integrate that”. There was no explanation of what either operation was, just the rules that you followed to obtain the result. I had no idea that we were looking at rates of change or at areas under curves. For the first time in my life, I found myself bewildered, and struggling - until a month later I happened to find myself reading a biography of Newton which actually explained what the purpose of calculus/fluxions was - and then it became easy, as it was obvious if a result was nonsensical.
For me it was completely mind-blowing, how someone could do fractions without understanding what they are? But I imagine, at school they probably could solve some problems, couldn't solve others, got C, moving on to the next lesson.
The Matika site looks really nice but I have difficulties comprehending the instructions. Even the very first one for first grade. “Children step by record.” What does that mean? I tried the next one. “During addition we write addends below each other…” What? If all addends are below, no addend is on the top. It makes no sense. Then, “…and the sum below the line” with no line in sight. What, where, which line, how? That was frustrating.
The whole "stepping" thing is a reference to how they (in the web page author's country) teach basic addition and subtraction at first grade. There is a carpet with numbers on the floor, you start at number zero, and do addition like "2+3" means "two steps forward, pause, three steps forward, now look at the number you are standing on". The carpet is situated so that from the sitting kids' position the zero is on the left, and the numbers increase to the right.
The idea is to turn integers into something "tangible", in a way that can later be extended to negative numbers.
So the instructions should be like: "You start at given number. Right arrow means a step forward to a greater number. Left arrow means a step backward to a smaller number. What number you end at?"
Sorry, I already know all these things by heart, so I didn't notice how the English instructions don't make sense. Guess I should contact the author about it.
So why the aversion to understanding? I suspect part of that is generational; if your parents sucked at math because they relied on memorization, they probably won't introduce you to math as an something worth understanding. It will either be "give up", or "work harder" but in the sense of memorizing harder. Not just your parents, but the entire culture around you will be like that. Another part is that most math teachers at elementary schools actually suck at math; because teachers are many, but people good at math are few and they have many better careers available. But another problem is the insistence of school system on everyone going forward at a predetermined speed -- sometimes understanding takes time, and when you don't have the time, you are forced to memorize; but once you start memorizing, you usually need to keep memorizing, because understanding can only be built on understanding the prerequisites.
Properly taught elementary-school math should be fun, like this: https://www.matika.in/en/ Fun makes people think.