Re:We're Being Erased from History
by jart on Saturday August 24, 2024 @11:32AM
(#41338988)
You're attacking a strawman. Authorship data like git commit history is about telling the story of how people brought a thing into existence. The journey can matter as much as the destination. Will AI be able to move forward on its own, if it has no knowledge of how it got there? I guess it's a question of how smart you really want it to be.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We're Being Erased from History
by kelseyfrog on Saturday August 24, 2024 @01:02PM
(#41339591)
Intellectual property isn't a valid idea.
Then you must be thrilled with the way AI training is being practiced.
Re:We're Being Erased from History
by kelseyfrog on Saturday August 24, 2024 @02:15PM
(#41340176)
Yes, I enjoy the creation of new technologies which can make the legal fabrication of intellectual property terminally unfeasible.
They may have indemnity against rent-seeking but they can still be judged for their behavior.
Re:We're Being Erased from History
by kelseyfrog on Saturday August 24, 2024 @03:40PM
(#41340873)
Right, but I'm not advocating for actions within the current system. I'm advocating for a change to the current system by drawing a contrast between legality and reality.
We have a collective tendency to forget that we're the authors of legality and tend to reverse our causal arrows. Reality should be reflected in the law, not be shaped by the law.
Law and money are both old world concepts. I care about code and attention. I also believe in respecting other people. Law was invented to formalize deeper concepts like respect. Just because the law is broken, doesn't mean it's ok to start disrespecting others boundaries and intentions. All progress is played out above the legal waterline. Code doesn't exist until it's written. That's the way it's always been. We also have a voice in that process.
Great, so when are OpenAI and Anthropic going to make their LLMs public domain?
Re:We're Being Erased from History
by cowboylowrez on Monday August 26, 2024 @12:46PM
(#41359042)
there are really no natural rights, except winning a contest. eat or be eaten, these are the only natural rights. every other right is a product of civilized society to put it simply. and civilized society thinks that renumeration for intellectual works is a good thing.
copyright looks to apply free market competition for authored works while protecting against those who wish to freeload. its even better than that, because freeloaders have the vast array of free stuff available and nobody would complain that you personally benefit from their use even if you don't contribute back.
but I do agree with you halfway, property rights are a social construct, but I disagree with the "invalid" part.