News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by Retric on Thursday August 22, 2024 @09:40AM (#41320165)
The economy grows or shrinks with productivity but advertising specifically is zero sum. Coke vs Pepsi makes a great deal of difference to those specific companies and little else.

If anything it’s slightly negative due to inefficiency because the winner isn’t the best product.

[dead]
Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by vundercind on Thursday August 22, 2024 @10:31AM (#41320721)
Rivalrous advertising spending between two megacorps everyone already knows is zero-sum. You’re spending money just because the other guy increased spending, and market share stays the same. But you can’t not spend or you might lose market share. Now you’re both spending more to achieve the same result.

[edit] zero sum in terms of the market-share game—the size of the pie stays the same, you’re just adjusting who gets how much. Negative sum for the overall game in the case that total spending increases.

Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by Retric on Thursday August 22, 2024 @10:49AM (#41320923)
You can still target advertising without knowledge details about the customer just the website it’s sitting on. Soap operas used to advertise a lot of dishwashing detergent even though there was no way to know directly if individual TV’s where on let alone who was watching them.

More broadly, individual companies failing is required for a healthy economy. Restaurants fail consistently yet there’s still plenty of places to eat out. Not every idea is useful forever and not every management team is competent.

Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by mjhay on Thursday August 22, 2024 @10:05AM (#41320409)
You're ignoring the fact that a customer buying from a business incurs an opportunity cost from other things they could have spent money on (or invested). In addition, it merely shifts the money. If someone is thinking about getting Subway, but sees a McDonald's ad and goes there instead, that helps McDonald's but hurts Subway.
Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by codedokode on Thursday August 22, 2024 @09:57AM (#41320326)
> cost of acquiring a customer > cost of serving a customer

For a successful and popular product the cost of acquiring a customer is low. Heavy investments in advertising are needed for unpopular, overpriced products that naturally have a low demand.

For example, almost everything that I buy I bought not because of advertising but based on the comparison of product price and quality.

Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by JohnFen on Thursday August 22, 2024 @10:13AM (#41320527)
And yet, somehow, businesses thrived even back when massively spying on people wasn't a thing they could do.
Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by glitchc on Thursday August 22, 2024 @05:10PM (#41324420)
Advertising is not zero-sum. It is a money multiplier.

To illustrate this, we start from the position that a new business creates net new value in the economy (on top of existing value). This is an economic maxim that must be true otherwise our GDP would never grow from 1770 standards.

Now, the new business has to allocate a percentage of its budget to advertising. It doesn't have a choice in the matter:

1) In a competitive market, not advertising places it at a competitive disadvantage to its rivals who are advertising.

2) In a non-competitive market, not advertising leads to a smaller overall market and a weaker position (loss of market cap and easier to disrupt).

Once the new business start advertising, other businesses become aware of it and either (a) choose to enter the market themselves, or (b) invest in advertising targeted at blocking/reducing this new market. Both cases result in more money spent on advertising. That's the multiplier effect.

Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by Retric on Thursday August 22, 2024 @05:28PM (#41324546)
> Advertising is not zero-sum. It is a money multiplier.

You misunderstand zero sum here. Gas stations can’t grow total gas sales making the selling of gas zero sum, but they very much provide a useful function in aggregate.

Advertising is going to exist with and without tracking individual users, the difference is simply relative value of undifferentiated content. Selling camping supplies on an outdoor website is targeting, but linking user’s history allows anyone to get a cut of premium revenue even if it’s lowest common denominator crap. But remove tracking of users and specialty content like local news becomes a lot more valuable and clickbait far less, a major public good.

> we start from the position that a new business creates net new value in the economy (on top of existing value). This is an economic maxim that must be true otherwise our GDP would never grow from 1770 standards.

I understand the point you are trying to make but existing companies also evolve their offerings over time. Nintendo in 1889 wasn’t selling video games.

Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by glitchc on Thursday August 22, 2024 @07:53PM (#41325230)
I think you missed the forest for the trees. I will make it very clear. The advertising business is a growth vector. It grows with the size of the economy. Singular industries may rise and fall (ex. ads for riding crops) but in aggregate, advertising always continues to grow. Zero sum means explicitly that the total pie stays the same, which advertising is not. It forces the pie to grow. And that's for a straightforward reason, because advertising is an arms race. A company can't afford to drop out, can't afford to fall behind.

> Advertising is going to exist with and without tracking individual users, the difference is simply relative value of undifferentiated content.

So what you mean to say is that targeted advertising is the same as mass advertising, that there's no benefit, perceived or otherwise, of targeting users. Well, I'm afraid you're very wrong. Both buyers and sellers of advertising love targeted advertising. For buyers, it makes the most efficient use of their budget allocation, and for sellers, it allows them to to take maximum advantage of user self-segmentation. The analogy of indiscriminate bombing being superseded by precision munitions is an apt one. There's no going back at this point.

Regulations will only distort the market further. The platforms will make the fines the cost of doing business, and pass them onto the buyers. The buyers, in turn, will pass that cost along to consumers in the form of higher prices. Every company will continue to pay for advertising because they can't afford not to. And so it will continue. All the fines will do is concentrate more wealth into the platforms and the government. And that's exactly what's happening in the EU with advent of GDPR.

Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by Retric on Thursday August 22, 2024 @09:31PM (#41325586)
> It grows with the size of the economy.

Your own words demonstrate the zero sum nature. During COVID YouTube had a huge spike in viewers as people stayed at home, but rates absolutely tanked because the value is defined between advertising budgets and available distribution not some inherent property of a viewer seeing an advertisement.

This is just like how gas in aggregate grows with the economy/oil prices not the efficiency of gas stations. It’s these external factors which make them zero sum.

> So what you mean to say is that targeted advertising is the same as mass advertising, that there's no benefit, perceived or otherwise, of targeting users.

No, I am saying tracking users is one of many methods to target users. The value of individual means of advertising varies, but the ability to target users doesn’t disappear when you ban tracking users. What changes is how valuable individual options are not the total value of all methods of advertising combined.

> There's no going back at this point.

Things often seem more stable than they actually are. Banning tracking is a tiny blimp compared to the kinds of changes you see after major Supreme Court decisions let alone major events like revolutions.

Re:84% want stronger online privacy laws, but Congress's cor... by JohnFen on Friday August 23, 2024 @10:35AM (#41329392)
> in aggregate, advertising always continues to grow.

Yes, like a cancer.

> Both buyers and sellers of advertising love targeted advertising.

Of course they do. But that's all at the expense of everyone who isn't in the business of buying and selling advertising.

> There's no going back at this point.

We'll see. I cannot accept that being forced to live in a massive surveillance state is an inevitability.

> Regulations will only distort the market further.

Bad regulations will. However, the appearance of ubiquitous spying by marketing companies are also heavily distorting the market. The introduction of rules to correct the serious misbehavior of these companies has the potential to correct, or at least reduce, the harm.

At this point, it's pretty clear that there is no other mechanism available to us. Simply resigning ourselves to bending over and taking it is not acceptable.