All the self help people use the same tactic. Often making the formula something that is counter intuitive - eg "How to work less and get more done".
Basically it encompasses a jumble of things that includes passion, patience, practice, and persistence. The 4 Ps is a coincidence.
Of course it's not a magical threshold, but when you can do something (in a focused and conscious manner) for 10 years, it's not hard to imagine that you have reached mastery.
The crime of fluffy writing (dunno about Gladwell's new book; didn't read it) is taking rule of thumb numbers and citing them as precision numbers as a way to seem exacting and scientific.
In other words, this isn't exactly something Gladwell made up. Practice does matter.
>"So, even if someone invests 3750 hours they can be just as good."
There is no evidence of this.
I wish I had a link, but it was in a non-free journal. I can look up the citation if anybody cares enough.
So, even if someone invests 3750 hours they can be just as good. This all seems besides the point though, when you are investing thousands of hours into something your not keeping track of 'hours put in' or 'exactly how good you are', its a passion and you're just into it. If success follows then great, if not then that wouldn't stop someone from continuing on.