I think there's a big difference between "data" and understanding principles of something. If you knowingly use "data" that your old employer hasn't made public for the benefit of your new employer, then you are probably not acting ethically. If your new employer is interested in you because of the things you know that they don't have access too, you are definitely not acting ethically. If you happen to know something that gives you an advantage, you can probably make advantage of it without disclosing that proprietary information to your new employer. Example: you now know that all avenues of trying to do X don't produce results. If you want to do Y at the new company, you can just not waste your time doing X, but you don't need to say why, and suggest trying a different approach. If someone else insists on doing X, you could still say that you think it's a bad idea, and suggest general reasons why, but probably you shouldn't say "No, at Blah we tried variants of X many times and it never worked." You can't unlearn the things you know, but you can handle that information ethically. Generally people have a pretty good read if what they're doing is ethical or not.
Whether you're in breach of a non-compete would ideally be exactly the same as whether you acted unethically or not. The purpose of enforcing the non-compete is to try to prevent the situation happening. In the UK, we rarely have non-competes and where we do, it'd have to go to a court to determine if you acted unethically or not (assuming honouring the contract is ethical) and attempting to prove if you did or not and/or the damage caused if you didn't.
But like, I say, there's a big difference between "data" (which you seem concerned about) and something you know/learned (which seems to be what your argument is predicated on). Using "data" would be corporate espionage, using something you learned because you understand the concept wouldn't be.
> effective putting you under indefinite unpaid non-compete
Not really, because most people do the decent thing, and there is generally no reason to suspect otherwise, and so these things never even go to court. If the company is convinced you have appropriated trade secrets, it probably will.
But people aren't under "indefinite unpaid non-compete" because most people just do the decent thing, and so most people are assumed to do the decent thing, and people just start their new job and get on with life. Non-compete agreements going to court almost never happens.
But it's important to add that I think this issue of trade secrets is different to non-compete, because years after you leave a company, if you leaked proprietary information of theirs that is still important in giving them a commercial advantage, you should expect to get sued even if you'd had a period of obeying a non-compete.
If the clients are already customers of the new company, then he can make them offers which he knows they would find tempting. There'd be nothing to suggest he ever did anything untoward, and even if a case was made, it'd be thrown out of court pretty quickly.
If the clients weren't already customers of the new company, but as soon as he joined they were approached, then there's a good case to be made that his actions were taken using commercially sensitive information. There's a good chance the court case would find against him. If it could be shown that other people cold called those clients, maybe phoning their public reception phone number and asking who they should contact, that's good evidence that there was no misuse of commercially sensitive information. If the new company suddenly knew exactly who to contact in procurement for the clients, and had phone numbers and e-mails, it's basically a slam-dunk.
If the prices they offer to the clients are in-line with the prices they offer other clients, there's not much of a case to be made. If the client is receiving unusually high levels of discount that are slightly better than what the old employer gave, it's pretty clear.
Like I say, in the UK, in general it is assumed that when someone moves to a new company, there will be some level of customer loss if there is a particularly good relationship between the employee and the client. That kind of stuff can easily be dismissed in court as a genuine existing close relationship (or maybe even the client knew them on linked-in and saw they'd changed to a competitor and approach them for a better deal) and almost no company would even bother trying to pursue this kind of case. In the opposite case, where it's very clear an employee had "stolen" a customer list, they definitely would pursue it because there'd be a high probability of winning that case.
Sadly, it's impossible to give a clear cut answer without talking about ethics. If you conduct yourself honourably and do the decent thing, there's close to zero chance someone would sue you for moving to a competitor, and even if they tried, it's almost certain they would lose the case. If you do the opposite, it's very likely they will sue you and also very likely they will win the case.
There's no magic line to try to skirt close to. But it's also not, as you seem to think, some kind of perpetual hold over a previous employee for people in the UK.
I also think the situation in the US is pretty similar. It doesn't really matter if you'd obeyed a year long non-compete, if you then gave year-old information to a competitor firm while it was still commercially sensitive, you could still be sued and have a good chance of being found at fault.
I am not sure what are "clients" here (I asked about customers but you have some distinction between these two terms, important enough to turn same behavior from benign to criminal). Let's make it simple: I work for Widgets & Stuff Ltd. and our biggest customer is Google. Google buys widgets at $20 a pop, and we make 100% profit on these because Google is not renegotiating price for some reason. The Widgetco Inc. offered me a job. I come and see it's not selling widgets to Google. I call Google (not using some secret number, which you seem to be so concerned about, it's literally Google, the famous tech company) and tell them that I am offering widgets at $15 now.
Who is a client and who is a customer here? Am I going to prison for espionage in UK? What is Widgets & Stuff Ltd. to do if Google decides to buy widgets from Widgetco?
Firstly, the difference between client and customer to me is that a client is someone who you've built up a strong business relationship with over years, maybe across different products, maybe with support or other value added services, and probably you might have a couple of people whose main job is looking after this relationship. A customer is much less personal, maybe they just bought a few things that represent a small fraction of your company's revenue, it might even be a fairly insignificant part of the revenue you personally brought to the company. Obviously, if a company loses a small customer it's annoying, but not a big deal. If a company loses a big client, it will have serious repercussions - maybe there's no longer work for an entire team.
> and our biggest customer is Google
This is the most important part of the information. It still doesn't give a full picture of the situation, maybe you have 1000 customers and Google is your biggest by revenue but still only a tiny fraction of your overall sales. In that case nobody cares, apart from maybe for PR. On the other hand, this "widget" might be really specialised and Google was 75% of the company's revenue. You can be very sure that if Google suddenly stop buying more widgets, and when asked why they reply by saying that they're buying from you at your new company at a cheaper price, they will immediately get their legal team preparing for a possible lawsuit and start investigating what information you had access to.
> Google buys widgets at $20 a pop,
This almost swings it the other way for me, as these widgets are relatively cheap commodity items that sound like they could probably be sourced from many other companies. If they can, then losing this customer to another that makes these same widgets is probably something that was on cards anyway, whether you moved to a competitor or not. Probably no case.
The significant thing though is revenue, not price. I assume the volume sold must be incredibly high, because you said they're the biggest customer.
> and we make 100% profit on these
I assume you don't mean 100% profit, because then you'd be making them for free. But whatever, it's an unusually high markup, and they'll want to protect that business investment if possible.
But, on the flip side, if these widgets are being produced at basically zero cost, then you should always expect a competitor to undercut you.
> The Widgetco Inc. offered me a job.
Why did they offer you a job? Did they hire you because you worked for a competitor and they'd seen through linked-in that you regularly mentioned being responsible for some of the big clients they wanted to poach. Or did you just appear on their search for "salespeople for blah widget"? Did you apply for a job there, and if so did you give them the impression that you'd be able to bring some of your clients with you? Or was it just a simple case of being able to get a job with slightly better pay, benefits or promotion opportunities?
> I come and see it's not selling widgets to Google. I call Google (not using some secret number, which you seem to be so concerned about, it's literally Google, the famous tech company)
It's not about it being a secret number, per se, it's about whether you had some kind of privileged connection to a key decision maker in the purchasing department because of your previous company. If so, that is commercially sensitive information. If any random person could e-mail this company, and the email would be read, taken seriously and acted upon, then it's probably not.
The fact that it's "the famous tech company" makes it even more improbable that they just happened to start buying things from your new company rather than your old as soon as you moved, and so much more likely that you were misusing the old company's commercially sensitive information.
> tell them that I am offering widgets at $15 now
There are several very telling bits of information in this phrase. "I am ... now" implies that you're continuing the established business connection in a way that "Hi there. I represent Widgetco Inc and we're selling widgets at only $15 each. Could you put me in touch with the revelant person and we'll go from there."
Now, again at that price point $15 and $20, and the fact that your company seemingly sells widgets that are interchangeable, then they're just commodity items and it sounds like normal business wins and losses, and so would probably be written off as bad luck by Widgets & Stuff if you left and then some other person at Widgetco Inc got a deal with Google. If, however, you were the main point of contact between Widgets & Stuff and Google, and then after moving to Widgetco Inc you became the main point of contact again, then it's a clear misuse of that relationship.
If you'd said, "I know Google buys a lot of these widgets. I can't be involved due to my previous connection with their existing supplier, but it's worth getting somebody to approach them.", then it's almost certainly fine, especially for commodity items that seemingly any company can make. Doing it that way leaves a paper trail that can trivially dismiss any attempt to later sue you. On the other hand, if Google being a customer of Widgets & Stuff was a trade secret, then disclosing it at all is a bad idea.
> Am I going to prison for espionage in UK?
That's a simple one. No. You'd only go to prison for stealing state secrets. Stealing commercial secrets would just be a breach of a civil contract, and the purpose of going to court would be to establish financial losses that result from that.
> What is Widgets & Stuff Ltd. to do if Google decides to buy widgets from Widgetco?
They would weigh up all the different things I mentioned above, and more, to decide whether to pursue it.
Again, the point I'm making is that if you don't intentionally use commercially sensitive information in the new company, you won't have anything to worry about. If you do intentionally use commercially sensitive information that harms your ex-employer and helps your new employer, then you do have something to worry about. Anything in between those extremes has the potential for litigation.
And again, to bring it back to the original topic, I believe you'd have largely the same outcomes in both the UK and the US relating to stealing commercially sensitive information, regardless of whether there was a non-compete in force or not. The only difference is that in the UK, even if there's a non-compete clause in your contract, it's almost never enforced unless the old company has a strong expectation that there will be misuse of trade secrets and is able to convince the judge that those loses outweigh your right to seek any work at the new company. Perhaps the outcome might be that you sign an affadavit re-affirming that you understand your obligation to not disclose such trade secrets, as a condition for the judge ruling that you can work for the new company.
The examples that were mentioned elsewhere in the thread, of restaurants in the US using non-competes to prevent their staff leaving to work for a competitor simply do not exist in the UK, because if a company did try to pursue such a case, it would be laughed out of court.
In the very few cases where somebody does steal trade secrets, then they can expect to get taken to court. This very rarely happens, and with a presumption of innocence, requires significant proof that this has occurred. It simply isn't something that a normal person, conducting themselves professionally needs to worry about.
> Hopefully you can see yourself how non-competes make it possible for people to switch jobs and simplify life for everyone.
Quite the opposite. How does a non-compete help a waitress paid $5/h switch jobs when the restaurant across the road pays $6/h, but she can't work there without surviving several months without pay? How does a non-compete help an accountant switch jobs? How does a non-compete help a programmer switch jobs? Simply, it doesn't. Whatever the profession, a non-compete does not help the employee at all. It only helps the employer keep wages lower, by restricting their employees ability to move to a better paid job.
The only case where non-competes are genuinely useful to a company, other than for restricting employees seeking better paid jobs elsewhere, is when an employee has access to sensitive company information and actively uses that information at a new company. A non-compete period would just slow that down, not eliminate it, and there are other legal ways of handling that situation should it occur.
Again, the same point: if you left the job where you used customer data then how do you deal with that data in your memory? Either you don't give any reason to believe you used it, least you're getting charged with espionage and this would include not working for the competition, effective putting you under indefinite unpaid non-compete. Or you don't perform your job duties, and this give no reason for someone to pay you.
If it's really like this in UK, I can see how you can think non-competes are not needed. I'd rather have an American non-compete where I get money and a defined term though.