News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Understanding Intel by ryukoposting on Monday August 19, 2024 @12:07PM (#41292215)
> The design of the CPU matters for this quality criterion only in the unlikely scenario when the design team was not competent and they have made a far from optimal design.

I think this is an overstatement in a couple of ways:

> unlikely scenario

We're still less than a decade removed from the final descendants of Bulldozer. We can't directly compare it to Zen because of the process differences, but Bulldozer sucked in several ways that weren't related to its 28nm process.

> made a far from optimal design

AMD and Intel continue to release improved x86 architectures. Alder Lake introduced heterogeneous cores to x86. Zen 5's dual decode path is less visible, but an innovation in its own right. If there is a long-term local maxima in x86 design, we haven't found it yet.

That's not to say flagrantly bad design is impossible (again, Bulldozer) - it's only to say that there are indeed two avenues to making a CPU better, even if one avenue (process) sets the ceiling for the other (architecture).

There are no comments on this comment yet.