Trust me, there will be plenty of time in the coming months for in-depth product reviews, spec comparisons, etc. ad nauseam.
But the entire site is crap. And I'll admit I'm saying that on a primarily emotional, rather than rational or practical, basis. The images are just straight links, the renderings are poor half-assed CAD drawings, and the colors make it seem like a play-dough ad.
I'm sorry, but this is not professional work. It looks like something I did in high school, in one weekend. As good as the product might be, the site is not good marketing, no matter how you spin it. It's shoddy and lazy. I'm honestly surprised at how poor it is.
It would be a lot more reasonable to ask him to show competitors within a similar industry who have produced a better launch site.
Personally, I think the site is fine except that I'm getting some pixelation on some of the images (especially the main one, which is scaled to match the screen size). But then, I work for Microsoft.
Oh, I do too. The site is fine, you're right. But for a company with the amount of resources yours has, and for a product launch as important as this is, fine is not good enough. It needs to be exemplary. This isn't—it's just OK.
Do you really think android was far superior product to Palm Pre? Or maybe the advertising had a bit to do with it...
I think there's about 10s worth of content there.
When the iPhone first came out, there was no nonsense about the brand and emotion without substance. They made EVERYONE want one.
Microsoft may have chosen not to appeal to us. But Apple has shown that you can do both.
Asking that question is like asking an Olympic sprinter why he can't be as fast as Usain Bolt, or scolding a successful musician for not selling as many records as Lady Gaga.
Compared to Apple, pretty much every company sucks at marketing. So what? Apple is an extreme outlier in its PR success, owing to a number of unique factors other companies cannot realistically replicate.
How would you answer your own question? Do you think there's a simple solution Microsoft hasn't figured out?
For the iPhone maybe, except for the non-subsidized price, but this was definitely not true for iPod and iPads.
The general consensus was the iPad was a giant iPhone and was going to fail among techies and the tech media.
When it comes to successful marketing, companies like Apple literally manage to mess with your mind:
http://www.tuaw.com/2011/05/17/bbc-loving-apple-looks-like-a...
Here is the documentary about this topic. It is fascinating:
Perhaps it's because I haven't received my crystal ball in the mail yet (Soon! /crosses fingers), but people seem to be making absolute judgments of a few hours. Microsoft can have other ads and other ways to promote it; it wasn't 'one ad or die'.
My reaction? Looks neat; let's see what unfolds.
Definitely doesn't make me want to buy one for a child or other family member.
Edit: I could see an image piece like this working as part of an XBox or game machine marketing. But seriously, the thing it makes me think of is a hypothetical Ridely Scott version of The Andromeda Strain.
And that minute long video, which screams Dudes, Droids, and ferrofluids: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dpzu3HM2CIo&feature=playe...
Which one do you think he will understand? To which can he relate more?
(Btw. I don't say iCloud is good. Microsofts Skydrive on win8 (or whatever they're calling their cloud offerings now, I really don't have an overview anymore) seems quite compelling - but it seems to me like they can't really communicate well enough what it does.)
Instead the video stood out as a black box - it looked a little incongrous just 'stuck there' in the middle of the page.
Seriously. How hard was that? I have to do a browser plugin upgrade just to watch and ad?! The whole ship is made of fail.
edit: no flash or silverlight, and yet both the MS video and the youtube one play fine
And thank goodness a technologically competent company is hosting the advertising for this new technological product. Such hosting is apparently beyond the technological capabilities of the maker of said product.
Edit: Ok all snark aside, this looks a pretty freaking cool piece of hardware.
Still, the website being off-and-on down on launch day is pretty facepalm.
It might actually be a hidden benefit. When I saw the error messages I thought to myself "wow, there is a lot of demand for more news of this..." Therefore, I must know more! (refresh, refresh, refresh... ahh... interesting.)
For all intents and purposes this should never happen on launch day for a groundbreaking product, BUT, in this case the marketing folks at Microsoft should chalk this one up as a success. In a big company like Microsoft, a marketing effort that causes an infrastructure problem is a big win for the marketing guys.
Now, Microsoft has to deliver the product. And the infrastructure guys have to deal with the traffic while the marketing folks are toasting each other with champaign. There aren't any OEM partners at that party though...
Look at the video they have for the consumer preview of Windows 8 ... it's more in the vein of what you are talking about.
Come to think of it, perhaps General Motors is using a similar ad agency?: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k_OfzaZcz9Q
The goal is not to convey information, but rather to form an emotional bond, whether conscious or subconscious.
However, as far as giving information about the product, I don't think it was too bad. Features from the video:
* Cover is a keyboard on the back * Cover is removable, and comes in many colors * Kickstand on the back * A little thicker than a USB plug
MSFT should be able to do better and show the kinds of things we can do with this that would get us excited.
One of the executives in my company was using Citrix on his iPad. He kept expecting the Citrix app to be, well, more app like. Instead he was stuck using a Windows application published by our Citrix farm on a touch interface. It wasn't a good experience, and now we're investigating converting a lot of our in house applications to iOS etc.
Now the Windows administrators? They're all over this type of thing, though they would never give up their workstations.
I'm not criticizing you, this sh*t happens to me every time too... (executives that want toys etc..)
And that's probably going to be the big selling point. "It's a bit like an iPad, but it comes with a cover that's also a keyboard".
In that minute, they have not told me anything about what the Surface can do for me, and why I should care about it. I'm absolutely baffled by that.
Yes, I might know what it is, and have some idea about what it can do, but if this was a television commercial, I'd bet money that such a campaign would be a quickly forgotten failure.