Re:The death of consistency in UI design
by potatolicious on Monday June 18, 2012 @12:44PM
(#4127271)
Agreed - note some of the most enduring new UI conventions we've come to expect in the last couple of years, all of which were pioneered by third-party apps bucking the trend (even in places where there was already established convention).
- Pull down to refresh (where Apple encouraged an explicit refresh button on the bottom of the screen)
- Swipe aside views (where Apple encouraged explicit navigation buttons)
- Slide aside menus (a la Path, where Apple expected tab bars to fulfill that role)
- Fan-out controls (a la Path, where Apple expected the use of drop downs)
The list goes on. I for one am happy that some people are unwilling to just follow the tried and true.
Re:The death of consistency in UI design
by bicknergseng on Monday June 18, 2012 @01:46PM
(#4127594)
Beat me to it. On a similar thread imagine if interface design hadn't evolved since the first 5 years of GUIs.
When Apple released its ipod (with the big wheel in the middle), it was nothing like the other players we were used to. Was it horrible? Was I annoyed by the difference? No, I thought it was cool, and I loved my iPod. Some years later, they did the exact same thing with the iPhone. Completely different, and yet, it set a new standard for design.
Now I understand the point of the article, and it's true that it's annoying to see every other small app coming up with new UI conventions. But I guess I'm not too radical about it: if this is the price to pay for innovation in UI design, I'll take it.