News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by dagmx on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:06PM (#41259318)
Honestly at the time of writing, only gjsman-1000 has given you the correct answer if somewhat incomplete. Everyone else is just telling you what they think should happen or putting it up to the difference in courts, while ignoring the evidence that Epic provided in the case.

The issue is not monopoly and this is where people get hung up. It’s about anticompetitive behaviour enabled by a monopoly (or any level of market dominance)

Google was found to be anticompetitive because even though they allow other stores and side loading, they were pushing OEMs to exclude other stores and making sweetheart deals to prevent apps going to other stores.

Hence they were using their market position to harm their competing stores.

Link to the findings https://www.theverge.com/23959932/epic-v-google-trial-antitr...

Apple has no competitor in the App Store for its platform outside of the EU, and therefore can’t be found anticompetitive on the same grounds that Google was.

They maybe found anticompetitive if they used their store to harm competition at the application level but that hasn’t been proven yet either. The closest has been in the EU (and to a lesser degree CA) where they were found in violation of anti-steering but those are distinct.

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by solardev on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:15PM (#41259388)
Man, that's one tortured legal philosophy... so it's more anticompetitive to allow alternatives and use incentives to deter them, than to forbid them outright? Crazy world we live in.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by dagmx on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:26PM (#41259477)
Well, because it’s about anti-competitive actions.

Again, it’s not about simply having a monopoly position.

Epic couldn’t prove that Apple had taken anti competitive measures. Google on the other hand had it in writing that they did. It was a slam dunk case from the get go

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by solardev on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:29PM (#41259502)
In a sane world, the very fact that Apple doesn't even allow alternative app stores should be in and of itself anticompetitive.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by dagmx on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:50PM (#41259699)
Well think about it this way:

Currently (in the US) no alternative stores for iOS exists.

No regulation exists to create multiple stores. In fact, even in the EU, the regulation only states that you have to do so after a certain number of users.

Being a monopoly is completely legal as long as you don’t actively prevent competition.

Apple maintaining the status quo is not anti competitive. Sure, no competition can exist but as long as Apple isn’t actively squashing competition, it is fine.

On the contrary, Apple would have to make effort to allow for competition. And without EU like regulations, there is no legal framework to compel a company to enable competitors.

Apple has been very careful to walk that fine line.

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by matwood on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:38PM (#41259585)
There is no law with being a monopoly or anticompetitive. A company must be found to be both. Proving a monopoly is the first hurdle that will continue to be challenging with Apple. That's why defining market is so critical in these cases. The government is already suggesting slices like 'performance smartphones' that make Apple look dominant.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by tzs on Thursday August 15, 2024 @07:29PM (#41261604)
> There is no law with being a monopoly or anticompetitive. A company must be found to be both.

Not quite. There is no need to prove a monopoly in order to prove a violation of US antitrust law. There FTC has a nice summary of the core federal antitrust laws here [1]. Some quotes:

> The Sherman Act outlaws "every contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade," and any "monopolization, attempted monopolization, or conspiracy or combination to monopolize."

...

> The Federal Trade Commission Act bans "unfair methods of competition" and "unfair or deceptive acts or practices."

...

> The Clayton Act addresses specific practices that the Sherman Act does not clearly prohibit, such as mergers and interlocking directorates (that is, the same person making business decisions for competing companies). [...] As amended by the Robinson-Patman Act of 1936, the Clayton Act also bans certain discriminatory prices, services, and allowances in dealings between merchants.

It's pretty much all about unfair competition and about attempts to create a monopoly.

[1] https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui...

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by matwood on Saturday August 17, 2024 @08:31AM (#41274073)
You're right, I spoke too freely and should have said legal methods of competition. What you're missing from your quote though is 'unreasonable'. Many types of restraint of trade, like exclusive business arrangements, are reasonable until the parties are at or near monopoly status. Or take price fixing that only works when the parties fixing the prices form a monopoly around the good.

To tie this back to Google, just being declared a monopoly will now change how they do business. Deals they made before are no longer on the table and would be deemed unfair because Google is a monopoly.

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by wtallis on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:36PM (#41259566)
Easier said than done. You still need some kind of criteria for deciding what is illegal tying vs justifiable integration. You cannot just decide what the outcome should be for Apple while avoiding the general question of how to draw the line that you want Apple to be on the wrong side of.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by paulmd on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:04PM (#41261817)
That’s how the law works.

For example nvidia is in hot water for the way they treat their partners: restrictions on what they can make, bundling of products, etc. Really a lot of the same stuff as intel and AMD did back in the late 90s/early 2010s with locking down their chipsets etc to force third parties out of the market (although this was never really enforced at the time).

Then contrast apple: apple has never sold individual components to partners in the first place. They will not sell you a M1 processor, only a whole MacBook or tablet. And that’s perfectly legal and not anticompetitive at all, actually.

What’s the difference? Intel and Nvidia allowed partners to enter this niche, and then crowded them out later. Apple never allowed anyone to enter this niche in the first place. So there’s no actual harm to partners or market competitiveness - there was never a market in the first place. The former is actually legally much worse than the latter - it’s perfectly legal to just sell a phone and not the chips.

Think of it like “promissary estoppel” for business relationships. If you make a promise (even a verbal one) and someone else incurs an expense based on that promise, and you renege, you are on the hook for damages because of the money they spent based on your promise!

Anticompetiveness is very similar in a sense. If you don’t allow third parties to enter the space, there is no harm to market competitiveness, because there is no market. Once other companies spend billions of dollars to try and enter the market, you can’t just kick them out after the fact. Kicking them out is in fact less fair than never letting them enter in the first place.

(leaving aside the mac clone era, which occurred when apple was so small and frankly almost collapsing that there was no actual argument they construed a monopoly at the time)

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by solardev on Friday August 16, 2024 @11:21AM (#41267186)
Great explanation, thanks!
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by matwood on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:31PM (#41259522)
Not sure why you've been downvoted since what you state was a key reason Google lost. They allow side-loading then took actions to prevent other stores from being side loaded.

The judge in the Apple case also agreed with positioning iOS as part of the larger gaming market where Apple is acting just like game consoles. The judge even said the 30% was fair relative to the market. The anti-steering was a minor finding against Apple.

I think the biggest risk for monopolistic behavior Apple has is with interop. It's one of the reasons I believe they have embraced RCS.

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by SllX on Thursday August 15, 2024 @05:05PM (#41260352)
> It's one of the reasons I believe they have embraced RCS.

This isn’t to disqualify any of your other points, but because it keeps getting missed I’m going to include the missing context:

The People’s Republic of China requires 5G phones going forward to support what they call “5G Messaging” and what we know as “RCS”. This is one of those it’s easier to comply and do it internationally than to only do it locally things, if you’re going to do it at all, and it costs Apple nothing additional by doing so.

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by solardev on Friday August 16, 2024 @11:22AM (#41267192)
Does that mean RCS is easier to wiretap and censor?
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by SllX on Friday August 16, 2024 @11:52AM (#41267472)
I have no idea if it’s easier to censor technologically, but it isn’t encrypted either and it is a carrier-based messaging standard.
Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by tantalor on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:10PM (#41259346)
> Apple has no competitor in the App Store

iOS and Android appstores are not distinct markets. They compete for the same users (mobile phone users).

Re:Judge tells Google: Play Store shakeup coming; punishment... by dagmx on Thursday August 15, 2024 @03:16PM (#41259394)
As much as you may say that out loud, it’s not how the market is defined and nobody has been able to interpret it your way in a legal context in any jurisdiction.

The legal precedent is that each store only services the ecosystem they’re on, and that is the scope of the market.

More so, Apple has argued and legally been accepted by the EU that the store for each of its platforms are scoped by the individual platform. So the iOS store is not the same as the iPadOS store.

If you can prove your case legally, there are companies that will pay you tens of millions of dollars. Till then, opinions to the contrary are just shouting in the wind.