Re:US Air Force avoids PFAS water cleanup, citing Supreme Co...
by 23B1 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @10:50PM
(#41242087)
Congress cannot delegate the lawmaking obligation to unelected agencies.
That's... exactly what this ruling correctly determined; that the power must remain with the people and their representatives.
Re:US Air Force avoids PFAS water cleanup, citing Supreme Co...
by toyg on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @03:39AM
(#41243567)
Then enjoy government efficiency falling off a cliff - and the polluted water that will result from it.
Institutional zealotry is rarely a good thing.
Re:US Air Force avoids PFAS water cleanup, citing Supreme Co...
by slooonz on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @04:13AM
(#41243784)
As French, our dual-branch judicial system for a long time seemed very weird to me — I didn’t really see the point of it. I must thank the US to provide a clear example why it is in fact so useful.
In France, the law would be typically written as "The water must be safe to drink. The list of banned chemicals and safety thresholds is to be set by the Supreme Court of the Administrative Branch" (Conseil d’Etat). That way you still do have a judicial oversight of agencies, but with a judicial branch which has more adapted procedures to those issues (for example you don’t have to wait for a case to go all the way up to the Supreme Court to adjudicate — it is literally part of the job of the Supreme Court of the Administrative Branch to be proactive in those matters).
Expecting the already-clogged lawmaking process to be ready to amend a law every time a new compound ends up in water, is extremely unrealistic.