Re:It took my savings and 14 years – but I'm about to cure a...
by haswell on Monday August 12, 2024 @03:32PM
(#41228363)
I know this comment is well-intentioned, but it lacks curiosity and seeks to shut down conversation instead of encourage it or explore why something might not be correct.
I share your concerns about woo-peddling and material that lacks rigor. I'm also concerned about a common attitude of over-adherence to "it's not real until there are rigorous studies and wide consensus" and even more concerned with the notion that exploring a subject inherently trivializes anything.
As someone dealing with a number of auto-immune conditions, I've had to become more open minded about the avenues I explore. That does not mean that I'm looking at claims about specific diets or "fringe" approaches as cures, but as considerations while on a long journey. Often those considerations don't withstand further scrutiny. Some of them turn out to be helpful.
You're absolutely right to call out the complexity of RA and caution against putting too much weight into interventions that at best "may improve" symptoms, but accusing people of trivializing the disease or widening the empathy gap just make no sense here, nor does the idea that posting a link is "promoting" that content.
I share your concerns about woo-peddling and material that lacks rigor. I'm also concerned about a common attitude of over-adherence to "it's not real until there are rigorous studies and wide consensus" and even more concerned with the notion that exploring a subject inherently trivializes anything.
As someone dealing with a number of auto-immune conditions, I've had to become more open minded about the avenues I explore. That does not mean that I'm looking at claims about specific diets or "fringe" approaches as cures, but as considerations while on a long journey. Often those considerations don't withstand further scrutiny. Some of them turn out to be helpful.
You're absolutely right to call out the complexity of RA and caution against putting too much weight into interventions that at best "may improve" symptoms, but accusing people of trivializing the disease or widening the empathy gap just make no sense here, nor does the idea that posting a link is "promoting" that content.