News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Faulty instructions in C910 RISC-V CPUs by dpeckett on Monday August 12, 2024 @01:16PM (#41226907)
Isn't this the Cathedral vs Bazaar debate all over again? All designs have flaws, but at-least with something like the C910 you can open a PR to fix it going forwards.

Sure the first revisions of a new design will be buggy, but over time with iteration and continuous improvement they'll only get better.

I don't think too many folks will be designing new RISC-V cores from scratch, in the same way that very few people build their own OS's. It'll be contributing features and bugfixes to existing designs (and designing custom extensions).

Re:Faulty instructions in C910 RISC-V CPUs by camel-cdr on Monday August 12, 2024 @01:29PM (#41227065)
Most RISC-V processors are proprietory, the C910 is partially open source, excluding the draft vector extension implementation where the bug was located.
Re:Faulty instructions in C910 RISC-V CPUs by dpeckett on Monday August 12, 2024 @01:45PM (#41227252)
Yeh it's a shame T-HEAD didn't release the source for the draft vector extension. Admittedly they had their reasons.

While it might be true, and remain true for high-end designs, we're really seeing a proliferation of mid-to-low end RISC-V SoCs out of china based on open source IP.

Re:Faulty instructions in C910 RISC-V CPUs by miohtama on Monday August 12, 2024 @04:43PM (#41229097)
Shoudln’t this be the reason for customera to prefer 100% open processors?