News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar (2021) by phailhaus on Monday August 12, 2024 @11:23AM (#41225488)
> I do think that the HVAC system could use permanent buttons, or at least persistent screen buttons.

Um, this is exactly what the article is about: Tesla used to do this. There used to be a persistent "defog" button right at the bottom, but now it's hidden behind the Temperature indicator, which looks like it only lets you adjust up/down.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar (2021) by thebruce87m on Monday August 12, 2024 @11:38AM (#41225672)
> Um, this is exactly what the article is about

The article is about being unfamiliar with a car after 5 minutes. If the button was a physical button you’d still have to look for it since you are still unfamiliar with the car.

Before downvoting, ask yourself:

* “Would this article exist if the person found the button within 5 minutes?”

* “Would this article exist if the person was familiar with the car?”

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar (2021) by dingaling on Monday August 12, 2024 @12:01PM (#41225970)
That's not the point of the article, but we'll take a corollary of your statement.

Imagine a physical button for the demister that's hidden behind a temperature display LCD that hinges down.

There's no indication that the temperature display moves or reveals anything, no affordances, other than on a statement on page 3-11-A of the vehicle manual. Would it be acceptable to be confused in that instance even after many five-minute periods?

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar (2021) by thebruce87m on Monday August 12, 2024 @12:04PM (#41226002)
Of course it would be. That’s not what my comment is about.
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar (2021) by dim13 on Monday August 12, 2024 @11:59AM (#41225933)
That's also, what's article is about.

> This is one reason why hard-buttons are so effective in old-school cars. They all use these same standard icons so it’s easier for new users to scan across them and find the one you want without any training.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar (2021) by mkroman on Monday August 12, 2024 @11:58AM (#41225930)
And they would've found it, because it wouldn't be hidden.