News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bevy's Game Engine Fourth Birthday by Ygg2 on Sunday August 11, 2024 @04:22AM (#41214757)
What games Godot had at year 4?

There is Tiny Glade for Bevy engine but not renderer.

For Rust itself, I think Veloren was somewhat successful but it's in dev.

Re:Bevy's Game Engine Fourth Birthday by daghamm on Sunday August 11, 2024 @04:36AM (#41214827)
Godot was often #1 or #2 choice in game jams then. Hence even without AAA titles and console support it had a huge amount of developers testing it and improving it.

I don't see the same thing happening with bevy. In fact, I see very few game developers using Rust. It's almost like fighting the borrow checker sucks the energy out of the creative process.

(My current side project is in Rust)

Re:Bevy's Game Engine Fourth Birthday by swiftcoder on Sunday August 11, 2024 @04:43AM (#41214847)
> Godot was often #1 or #2 choice in game jams then.

The major difference is that Godot is designed around an editor. That makes the on-ramp significantly easier (especially for folks coming to Godot from Unity or Unreal).

Bevy is, in this context, more of a framework than an "engine" in the modern sense. There isn't yet a Rust-based equivalent to Unity/Unreal

Re:Bevy's Game Engine Fourth Birthday by runevault on Sunday August 11, 2024 @04:49AM (#41214869)
Worth noting Bevy is trying to figure out their own editor which is intended to be built in Bevy, same way Godot's Editor is a Godot application. Until that happens only a more hardcore audience is likely to use the engine I agree. I know I'm waiting for both being closer to 1.0 and the editor before I take a serious dive into Bevy.
Re:Bevy's Game Engine Fourth Birthday by Ygg2 on Sunday August 11, 2024 @05:52AM (#41215092)
Parent asked for games. I queried about same level of quality games when Godot was just as old (around 2018 it was 4 years old).

Comparing game to game jam, is like comparing a house to Lego house models. Apples and oranges.

> I don't see the same thing happening with bevy.

I don't see eye to eye then. Make a good UI, slap some lua via wasm and you'd get similar work environment to Godot.