Re:The Third Atomic Bomb
by advisedwang on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:14AM
(#41198715)
The viable alternative would have been demanding a surrender but stating that The Emperor will remain as a constitutional monarch - which is what the US ended up imposing anyway because it was the logical way to forestall resistance from a radicalized population. Such a demand would likely have resulted in a surrender before the atomic bombings.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Third Atomic Bomb
by otherme123 on Friday August 09, 2024 @02:35AM
(#41199295)
We have records of Japanese high rank military wanting to keep fighting after the dropping of the second bomb. They figured out the USA might have a couple more nukes, so Japan should endure them four and keep fighting.
As said in other threads, it was the nukes and the soviets invading what finally forced the surrender.
The earliest surrender request wasn't merely just for the emperor to stay in power. Japan also wanted to keep the territories they had acquired and manage all post-war trials of the military in-house.
Any American general or politician that agreed to these terms would have been seen as a fool or a coward, especially after Pearl Harbor, Bataan, Singapore, etc.