Many "bright spots" aren't really manageable: one runs all around my room and it's called a wall. The other follows me everywhere I go and it's called my face.
A bright picture on the monitor (say, a Google page) will beat reflections in most situations. But as soon as I open something darker - say the Sublime Text editor in its default (and best) color theme, and it's a friggin mirror.
As for "shimmer", I'm afraid it must be a problem of lower quality monitors. My good ol' NEC 1990FX gives me nothing of the sort.
If you can control your lighting environment and manage direct reflections (bright spots behind you), glossy isn't a problem. I just got a glossy monitor after using nothing but matte, and it's a fair bit clearer. Another thing to consider is the "shimmer" in anti-glare monitors, where slight movements of your head cause the bumps in the AG coating to reflect different colours depending on the angle. I don't mind it, but some people do.