News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by gspr on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:03AM (#41168456)
I'll bite. Not because I think I can change your behavior, but just so that others passing by don't end up taking your comment as having value.

> First it's global warming, then ice age, then again global warming...

Imagine a car that's lost a wheel and is careening down the highway out of control. The passenger screams "the truck behind us is gonna ram us!". Then: "we're going to faaaast, slow down!" Then it's "watch the barrier on the left, go right go right!", and then finally "watch the lightpole on the right!"

I assume you ridicule this passenger saying he doesn't even seem to know what the problem is?

> Then when they realize we have realized that they don't know what they are talking about they use vague terms as "climate change" to gaslight us into thinking they know what they are talking about.

It's impressive, really. Thousands and thousands of scientists spend their entire careers studying the physics of the atmosphere. From this they conclude, through painstaking work, backed up by data, that the atmosphere is becoming warmer – i.e. more energetic – due to human activity. The effects of this is aggrevated extremes. Hotter heatwaves. Colder cold snaps. Drier droughts. Wetter floods. And potentially (and now we're not in established science, but rather informed speculation) collapsing ocean currents that can lead to much colder temperatures in some places.

Yet you, brilliant NotGMan, you throw out all of that. You lean back, hammer your keyboard, and declare that these brilliant people "don't know what they are talking about". Unlike you, oh brilliant NotGMan, of course! _You_ know! Right?

Come on. Spare us.

Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by a-french-anon on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:13AM (#41168512)
> It's impressive, really. Thousands and thousands of scientists spend their entire careers studying the physics of the atmosphere. From this they conclude, through painstaking work, backed up by data, that the atmosphere is becoming warmer – i.e. more energetic – due to human activity.

All good until you understand that unless you are part of those experts (true experts, the one who never parrot anything and won't fall to ego self-tricks), you need to prefix your paragraph with "the scientific consensus brought to me by mass medias is:".

Fact is you seem very vulnerable to Gell-Mann amnesia compounded by Wikipedia "reliable sources" bias, from the way you write.

Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by gspr on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:23AM (#41168550)
Feel free to correct me. There's of course limited actual scientific substance that fits into a dozens-of-words HN comment, but any improvement is welcome.
Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by a-french-anon on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @03:43AM (#41168662)
I read the climategate emails myself - instead of reading Snopes and co. "factchecking" - and you can too. There is no proof of a "big lie" in it, but plenty of malpractice and lack of scientific integrity.
Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by gspr on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:23AM (#41168816)
I'm terribly confused. I don't see any corrections in what you wrote.
Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by a-french-anon on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @04:49AM (#41168946)
The "correction" (more like a warning) is in the trust one should have in those institutions and the data they produce.

Thus, treating anyone skeptical of the complete theory of human-induced global warming (which is different from not wanting to reduce pollution, mind you) as a troglodyte who "goes against the SCIENCE^tm" isn't wise at all.

Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by gspr on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @06:17AM (#41169391)
> Thus, treating anyone skeptical of the complete theory of human-induced global warming (which is different from not wanting to reduce pollution, mind you) as a troglodyte who "goes against the SCIENCE^tm" isn't wise at all.

I assume you by this mean that it's not wise to treat everyone who goes against the consensus as a troglodyte. Not that everyone who does so should be exempt from being treated as a troglodyte. The latter would be pretty silly.

I'm not doing that. I'm simply pointing out that if someone goes against said consensus, they damn well be prepared to provide the evidence of why they're right. That burden does not fall on those who assume that the vast body of established science is, in fact, correct. Someone thinking that they can just armchair their way out of scientific consensus is, indeed, a troglodyte.

Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by a-french-anon on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:32AM (#41169794)
You're implying that the only reasonable reason to doubt data is contradicting data. Which is what I'm objecting to, since funding and media representation in science certainly isn't favourable to this way of thinking.

Sometimes, "I'm not sure" or "I don't know" is wiser than "nothing better to challenge it".

The crux of the problem in your post is the use of the words "consensus" and "established" when these can easily be manufactured (and the infamous climategate shows such social engineering, even without debating the scientific truth or untruth of the matter). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_IQ_Controversy,_the_Media_... is a very good illustration of the problem at hand (ignore the possibly loaded title, it's not what you may think)

Re:Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean current n... by gspr on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @08:04AM (#41170028)
> You're implying that the only reasonable reason to doubt data is contradicting data.

No. I'm implying that the only reasonable reason to doubt massive amounts of data that has been, and is being, actively studied by thousands upon thousands of experts for decades, is contradicting data. Perhaps more importantly, I'm implying that armchairing an opinion on the matter carries zero weight.

> Which is what I'm objecting to, since funding and media representation in science certainly isn't favourable to this way of thinking.

Science's very imperfect funding structures do indeed cause worthwhile endeavours to go unexplored. That's sad. But irrelevant here, as it does not invalidate the conclusions from endeavours that are funded.

> Sometimes, "I'm not sure" or "I don't know" is wiser than "nothing better to challenge it".

Absolutely! For example when evidence is scant and a problem is under-studied. My problem is that you and OP seem to leap from that fact to that always being true. Climate change is not such a case, and unless you have large amounts of contradictive data, you're an idiot for saying "I don't know". And if you did have vast amounts of contradicting data, you'd bring it!

> a-french-anon 24 minutes ago | parent | context | flag | on: Is Europe headed towards a new Ice Age as ocean cu...

You're implying that the only reasonable reason to doubt data is contradicting data. Which is what I'm objecting to, since funding and media representation in science certainly isn't favourable to this way of thinking.

Sometimes, "I'm not sure" or "I don't know" is wiser than "nothing better to challenge it".

> The crux of the problem in your post is the use of the words "consensus" and "established" when these can easily be manufactured

No. You clearly have zero clue how science works.

> (and the infamous climategate shows such social engineering, even without debating the scientific truth or untruth of the matter).

?!