Re:Stop Killing Games – Almost at 160k signatures
by johnnyanmac on Monday August 05, 2024 @05:16PM
(#41165697)
My personal opinion is that an always-online game isn't even your property. No more so than an account here on Hacker News has me own HN/Ycombinator. It's their server and if it shuts down tomorrow that's unfortunate. But perfectly within their rights as handling their property.
In a casual legal sense, I feel it will ultimately come down to how and what a court considers a good, and how much of a digital good you own. I can see an alternative argument in a case where, say, you end up buying a "new" game at WalMart for a server that is no longer up. In that extreme case I can understand feeling like you were swindled (I can't think of a case where this happened, but I wouldn't be surprised about this occurance). So I can understand an argument where there should be some sense of game you buy when you buy a game.
In a casual legal sense, I feel it will ultimately come down to how and what a court considers a good, and how much of a digital good you own. I can see an alternative argument in a case where, say, you end up buying a "new" game at WalMart for a server that is no longer up. In that extreme case I can understand feeling like you were swindled (I can't think of a case where this happened, but I wouldn't be surprised about this occurance). So I can understand an argument where there should be some sense of game you buy when you buy a game.