The point is this adds a burden to small producers, particularly upstarts, while giving anti-competitive avenues of action to incumbents. Even if you’re complying with the rule, there is a cost to proving compliance and dealing with regulators.
Why shouldn’t you be able to sell macaroni if your machinery isn’t precise enough to meet those tolerances every time? (And why is that the federal government’s business.)
Because there is a standard to what "macaroni" is?
Otherwise call it something else. You can still sell pasta.
Having standards for food is very nice for citizens. For me it makes cooking far easier knowing if something actually is what it says it is. It actually matters.
Look I fully agree we need oversight for things like supplements and chemicals.
But macaroni?
Standards do that.
If you want to sell something like macaroni but doesn't fit the standard, you can, just call it something else.
In regulatory parlance macaroni = pasta [1].
[1] https://fdastorytime.com/2018/10/10/name-that-food-macaroni-...
How often do you switch macaroni brands?
The standard would apply to all, including whatever I buy.
Of course. You’re using consumer search costs as your argument for regulation. If you don’t switch brands, that cost is incurred less frequently. You’re using the brand, not the rule, as your filter.
I don't even have to search, that's the point. I know what the thing is based on the name, done. I cook, I know what the results are.
Yes, you're avoiding a search cost. That's your argument for standardising the name. You're choosing a measure of standardisation in exchange for restricted variety and a marginally-higher price. (Even if you don't perceive either.) The utility of standardised labelling is reduced consumer search costs.
If you aren't changing brands frequently, you aren't choosing based on the word "macaroni." You're choosing based on the brand. You now what Kraft macaroni (or whatever) tastes like. You don't know what any macaroni tastes like, because they all taste very different, because the thickness of a pasta is one among many variables in play.
And the thickness of it, no less. Not the ingredients. Not the nutritional content. The thickness.
This is almost certainly intentional. It reduces competition from imports since anyone who wants to distribute in America has to pay to repackage.
Do you really think the American public is better served by being protected from extra-thick or thin macaroni? What fraction of Americans know the difference between regulation-standard macaroni and other pasta?
> call it something else. You can still sell pasta
Sure. Too bad if you didn’t hire a lawyer before you started selling macaroni.
I have no idea what your other statement means.
Sure. But this is arbitrary.
The vermicelli definition doesn’t match Italy’s, for instance. So you’ve “protected” Americans from the competition of Italian producers who can’t pay to repackage.
> no idea what your other statement means
Point is I would love to have obscure definitions around what my product should be that arbitrarily match my current offerings. If anyone tries to compete I can put them out of business for making an honest mistake, or force them to have to market convolutedly. (Can’t be mac ‘n’ cheese if it isn’t made in a factory!)
> So you’ve “protected” Americans from the competition of Italian producers who can’t pay to repackage.
Any food producer who wants to export to the US already has to pay for a US-specific label, including ingredient list and nutritional info. In fact, that would be true for almost any other country as well.
And that's a good thing. If you can't even bother to print a label that tells the buyers what it's made of, in a language they can read, forget about it.
Nobody dies if someone's macaroni is thicker or thinner than another's.
> Any food producer who wants to export to the US already has to pay for a US-specific label
Plenty of imported foods don't do this. They're supposed to [1]. But as long as you stick to specialty stores, the trade association [2] is unlikely to go after you.
[1] https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidan...
I quite like this setup. It's nice to know the difference between cheese and "cheese product".
If you know. If you’re Kraft, you do this. If you’re making homemade mac ‘n’ cheese, you get a cease and desist from Kraft. (Or god forbid trying to sell Italian vermicelli.)
Let’s say your small producer can afford to hire a macaroni lawyer to figure out what’s going on. Who do you think is their regular client? How many could even pass conflicts? You may very well have no practicing macaroni lawyers in your state, which means you’re now getting someone reading the rules for the first time versus a team with warm contacts at the FDA and USDA.
Why would you believe this?
There is macaroni law [1]. (With a paywalled reference [2].) There is a macaroni trade association [3]. There are macaroni lawsuits [4].
It would be absurd for there not be lawyers who specialise in pasta/macaroni. (They're the same thing under federal law [5].) What would be less surprising is if they all work for the trade body and its members.
[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/21/139.110
[2] https://www.aoac.org/official-methods-of-analysis/
[4] https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F2/345...
[5] https://fdastorytime.com/2018/10/10/name-that-food-macaroni-...
Like, sure, in theory it seems nice to have some limits on what sellers are allowed to call macaroni. But there's a huge cost to these laws/regulations that goes beyond just the actual cost of adhering to the law. In my opinion any time the government does anything to intervene in private affairs it ought to have much stronger justification than just "wouldn't it be nice if..."
And who do you think are the macaroni lawyers’ largest clients?
The purpose of this rule is to ensure only certain people can produce macaroni.
You keep saying that, is it true?
I have a huge variety of macaroni and pasta options at my local store, made by all sorts of different suppliers, including small local businesses...
Yes. Specifically for Italian pastas. There is an import/export lobby that benefits from disparate labelling requirements. It came up during the pandemic around bucatini, which the FDA considers a macaroni product [1].
Of course, none of this matters if you can afford it. Plenty of Italian producers will ship you food labelled as furniture. But that is expensive since to set up.
Every supermarket food has layers of these compliance costs built into the price.
[1] https://www.grubstreet.com/2020/12/2020-bucatini-shortage-in...
Oddly enough, there's a ton of De Cecco and Bucatini at my local grocery store.... conspiracy over?
You asked for a source, couldn't manage to read it, couldn't manage to have it even summarised for you into simpler English and concluded conspiracy.
And yes, the shortage is over. But the article goes into why there was a shortage in America. And it had to do with requirements around macaroni products.
On a certain level, the current system works. Supermarkets serve industrial food that can be sold at a solid profit. Those profits pay some people more who can then buy a greater variety of food for cheaper than is broadly available. Win win.
De Cecco is not an unknown brand fighting against some massive conspiracy. They've been in the US for a long time ... I really don't think it supports your theory. De Cecco has been one of the brands I buy often for, I honestly don't even know how long, seems like forever.
> Why shouldn’t you be able to sell macaroni if your machinery isn’t precise enough to meet those tolerances every time?
The level of precision needed to consistently meet those tolerances is less than the precision of the extruders in a Play-Doh Fun Factory that you might find in a typical preschool.
It's an easy argument to make for sure, and likely true-ish. It's fun to come up with examples of providing paper copies to each individual. But I don't need a paper copy, and I can't remember the last time I felt compelled to read a law, maybe never?
Does it matter that it's "it’s a federal crime to enter a post office while intoxicated"? Are these examples really what the author is concerned about?
"By federal decree, macaroni must have a diameter between 0.11 and 0.27 inches, while vermicelli must not be more than 0.06 inches in diameter."
That's fine with me, that just means there's consistency across a product... that seems almost absurd to take issue with.
There are some examples later on of abuses, but those strike me as abuses that if it wasn't one misapplied law, it would be another. The existence of law when someone makes a poor choice doesn't make the law the problem.
I feel like a lot of these calls are really just appeals for "reforms" that aren't there for me, they're there for those who already have an advantage over me in the legal process...