News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by parkaboy on Monday August 05, 2024 @01:47PM (#41163565)
I wish there were a solution to managing whatever the equivalent of software-creep (law-creep?) in this space. Are there any examples of countries/governments that have successfully implemented such systems.

Either way, I don't like how things (hot takes from people, journalists, politicians businesses, whatever) are constantly framed as being pro/anti laws (or regulation). This seems to always at the end of the day serve "the elites" in one way or another: whether it's adding regulations to keep out competition from the little upstarts or getting rid of it to expand marketshare at the expense of consumer-harm.

Question should always be pointedly reframed as: do we have the "right" laws. Not as: do we have too many or too little. This ultimately means nothing and feels like a distraction from the bigger issues.

/end arm chair rant.

Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by delichon on Monday August 05, 2024 @02:35PM (#41164016)
That's the idea behind a constitution of enumerated powers, but those appear to lose their restraining force over a few generations.

I'd favor an amendment placing a sunset clause on every statute, and no omnibuses, such that the legislature only has enough time in session to keep a finite set of laws in effect.

Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 05, 2024 @02:42PM (#41164082)
> placing a sunset clause on every statute, and no omnibuses

Watch out, murder statute sunsets tomorrow and the Congress is gridlocked! Why are they gridlocked? They can’t string together broad compromises without everyone suing over what constitutes an omnibus.

Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by AnimalMuppet on Monday August 05, 2024 @02:49PM (#41164153)
Fair, but...

You get the Congress you vote for. If you need Congress to work together instead of acting like idiots, vote for people who will work together instead of acting like idiots. If you won't, this is the kind of Congress you get.

We haven't been feeling the pain because of the executive branch. But now Chevron is overturned...

(Also, murder is going to be against state laws even without federal ones, so this won't turn into the murder crisis that you suggest.)

Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 05, 2024 @03:03PM (#41164317)
> You get the Congress you vote for

You also get the people your country comes with ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.

> murder is going to be against state laws even without federal ones, so this won't turn into the murder crisis

Fair enough. There might be truth to bills passed without a supermajority having an automatic sunset. The benefit there being it could be rolled back retroactively.

That said, Congress loves a crisis. Having the existence of every Department, agency and court subject up for grabs if the Congress (or any legislative body) falls into temporary paralysis sounds like a good way to justify a coup.

Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by rqtwteye on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:49PM (#41165464)
The US voting system doesn't give you the Congress you vote for. We saw that with Ross Perot in the 90s. 19% of votes and zero representation.
Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 05, 2024 @05:13PM (#41165672)
> US voting system doesn't give you the Congress you vote for. We saw that with Ross Perot in the 90s. 19% of votes and zero representation.

The President and Congress are separate things.

Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by rqtwteye on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @07:58AM (#41169986)
The same thing would happen with a party that receives 20% of the vote. No representation
Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by Have7878forever on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @01:29AM (#41168057)
They won't. A lot of Americans love to purge Congress men and women legally. You can be 100% assured that example of gridlocked will not happen. Abortion might. Vote ID might. Metric vs English unit standardazition might. Murder? Hahaha zero chance.
Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by mike_hearn on Tuesday August 06, 2024 @02:24AM (#41168291)
Not very likely. Even "gridlocked" Congresses pass a lot of legislation, it just doesn't attract much attention.
Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by 6510 on Monday August 05, 2024 @04:27PM (#41165246)
Sounds like a fun idea. I think we should elect and hire a committee to delete laws. Make it a fork of the law making formula.
Re:America Has Too Many Laws – An excess of restrictions has... by amy-petrik-214 on Monday August 05, 2024 @10:34PM (#41167370)
Let's get concrete here on the BS laws.

Does the law hope to prevent people from causing harm, physical, financial, etc, to others or their property? Keep it.

Does the law aim to prevent people from harming themselves, excluding suicide? Toss it out, freedom. [i.e. heavy taxes on soda; mandatory helmets]. Some jurisdictions try to enumerate every little possible way a bad thing could happen and make it a fineable offense, and it comes off as very much "invasive HOA" energy

Does the law aim to indirectly incentivize particular behaviors for political goals? Toss it [i.e. some parts of California have fully failed permitting systems which prevent any new houses from being built whatsoever, which is great for the environment since all development has been permanently halted. the faulted law is gladly allowed to persist with the hidden political reason behind it]

Now as for monopolies I think we have entered a bizarre system of mostly duopolies. The OS duopoly. the cell phone duopoly. search engine duopoly. Streaming duopoly. Social media duopoly. the stock markets is a duopoly. our political system is a duopoly. coke and pepsi. and so on. what we do need on the point of looking out for the "little upstarts" is a very careful investigation of these duopolies to see if they are truly competing for all their worth, or if there's a backroom agreement on things. I believe tech is a little thicker on the backroom agreements