Ken Robinson, who makes my favorite TED talk IMHO, talks about this and how odd our education system is when looked at objectively from the outside in.
http://www.ted.com/talks/ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_crea...
His followup, as well as the RSAnimate (you can find them by clicking "Full Bio>>" on the right), are good followups to his ideas.
One of the most powerful quotes, to me, is from the RSAnimate:
We still educate children in batches. We put them
through the system by age group. Why do we do that?
Why is there this assumption that the most important
thing kids have in common is how old they are? It's
like the most important thing about them is the date
of manufacture.
Not only do we crush learning out of children, but creativity suffers as well.The program at the school had 1 large building, which was divided into 4 classroom with some common space in between. For each class period, you went to the class taught at your level. So you could go to the 1st grade math, or you could go to the kindergarten math.
I lived there for 2 years, and basically took 1st grade as kindergarten aged, and 2nd grade as 1st grade aged.
The worst part was moving, and having to "re-integrate" with the system. I had to take the age appropriate 2nd grade. My parents wanted me to skip directly to 3rd grade, but the school rejected that.
Which of course is why it's a political non-starter. The bureaucratic imperative is bigger budgets and centralization.
In addition to the one-room style of education, they had older students mentor younger one, an instruction model that enabled students to learn at mixed pace (accelerated for subjects the student was "good" at, slower for those they were't), music education that included learning to play an instrument at the kindergarden level, and foreign language at the 1st grade level (language choices included: french, spanish, russian, cantonese and many others)
Edit: Specifically, the school employed the Reggio Emilia approach (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reggio_Emilia_approach)
Maybe Shakespeare was born with the ability to write the best plays and poetry. But isn't it more likely that his talent started small and grew big, and that the people who helped it grow should be commended and admired?
Creativity is very important, yes; but it feeds on knowledge (creativity is the product of clashing together seemingly unrelated fields of knowledge). You don't have ideas about things you know nothing about, or if you do, they're usually useless.
On the other hand, if you assume it's designed to produce reliable, obedient consumers who won't rock the boat, it all makes perfect sense.
You would probably enjoy The Underground History of American Education (http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/chapters/index.htm).
(http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7036880.stm)
(http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/4907638.stm)
(http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/4331528...)
Of course, that means also banning all the legitimate uses of cameras, implying that the school thinks students' primary use of cameras is sexting, which I find obscenely offensive.
Have you tried a freedom of information request?
I wanted to know how many CCTV cameras they have. We in the UK are a heavily monitored population (here's a frustratingly thin article with a few details, hinting at a rich data set that is not made available. (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/8159141.stm) ) It's bizarre that her tax money (as a child she doesn't pay much, but she will pay VAT on a few items and her parents certainly pay taxes) is used to provide state surveillance and to prevent her photographic record of her dinners.
There are many reasons to prevent children taking phones and cameras to school. This reason is a really really stupid reason.
How wrong-headed it is to take active measures against a child who is showing an interest in writing; civics; nutrition; and so on.
EDIT: The father has appeared on BBC Radio 4's "Today" news programme. (about 7:20 for anyone 'listening again'.) He has said that the school has been very supportive, and that the decision was taken by the council. He sounds pretty balanced about it. We crush the joy of learning out of children.