As you say, we don't have enough data to know one way or another, but even when we do, there will still be no paradox.
My favorite hypothesis is that we are early. Due to low metallicity in the early universe it’s possible that advanced life only became likely “recently” (as in the last few billion years) and we are part of the first crop. We may be an early example in the first crop because our planet is particularly friendly to advanced stable life, so maybe a bit of rare Earth mixed in. Most other biospheres might be more hostile and take longer to produce anything capable of space flight.
We don’t see star travelers all over the place because for the most part it’s too soon. There might be a few early birds out there but few intelligences are that advanced yet.
We don’t even know the paradox is real since we haven’t explored our own solar system enough to rule out aliens or artifacts of their visits in our back yard, nor can we rule out advanced observers intentionally not revealing themselves for any number of rational reasons. There could be an abandoned underground alien base on the Moon and we’d have no clue. We have barely gone anywhere.
If we hit, say, the level of development in The Expanse and still find nothing (no protomolecule haha) then maybe we can say there is definitely a paradox.
There’s also the assumption that there is a single discrete big and dramatic great filter. That’s the Hollywood version. In reality there could just be a continuous probability of failure due to any number of events whether endogenous or external spread across billions of years that amounts to a great filter. The probability per day of “biosphere failure” or some other condition that dooms a potential spacefaring intelligence doesn’t need to be high to amount to a probability near 1.0 over geological time scales.
Let’s say given we are sending our probes and capsules we are probably at least 50% of the way there. If the cumulative great filter were near 1.0 probability of failure this would imply a 50/50 probability of our success. Those are of course made up round numbers just to illustrate how that would work. We have no way to know what the actual numbers are because we have a sample size of one.
The whole thing is just speculation until we have more actual data.