News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wheel of Lunch: Killed by Yelp after 15 years by kragen on Saturday August 03, 2024 @11:30AM (#41147152)
i don't think newspaper restaurant critics count as 'reliable sources' in wikipedia with respect to the questions people are interested in here, such as whether the chicken is overcooked. i am pretty sure that if you try to put an assertion like that into a wikipedia article about a restaurant, it will be reverted as unverifiable pov pushing, regardless of how many newspaper restaurant critics you can cite in support of it. you can probably cite them for things like when the restaurant opened and why it moved to its current location, as well as use them for evidence of notability
Re:Wheel of Lunch: Killed by Yelp after 15 years by ghaff on Saturday August 03, 2024 @11:43AM (#41147238)
I don't really expect something in Wikipedia to get into the nuances of particular dish quality. But, in general, I would expect that--to the degree Wikipedia gets into the quality of a particular restaurant--a New York Times review would carry a lot of weight. In general though I agree that Wikipedia is probably not the place for restaurant reviews even to the degree they're sources from well-known restaurant critics.
Re:Wheel of Lunch: Killed by Yelp after 15 years by kragen on Saturday August 03, 2024 @12:22PM (#41147502)
this is generally limited to things that wikipedia editors of vastly opposing viewpoints can agree on, like whether and when the restaurant was awarded a michelin star

like, imagine a vegan, a devout hindu, a muslim, a carnivore, a neighborhood kid, and a foodie editing an article about a texas steakhouse that is known for its barbecued pork. whatever text any of these people finds unfairly biased is going to get deleted from the article, and what's left is what they can agree on

this process produces astoundingly reliable articles on contentious topics like the armenian genocide, but the results are predictably of poor literary quality, and generally not very useful for things like guessing which restaurant you would prefer to eat at