The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is the Loss of Community

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by dmkolobov on Friday August 02, 2024 @02:44PM (#41141448)

Growing up in Nashville I've frequently heard that religion is a prerequisite to ethics. While I disagree in principle, I struggle to come up with an example where philosophy and ethics are discussed in a secular setting outside of school(academia included) and politics.

It would not surprise me that on the whole our society is worse off for lack of a widespread secular tradition of discussing these concepts with your community.

edit: substitute "secular setting" for "secular state", definitely not arguing for the integration of church and state.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by silverquiet on Friday August 02, 2024 @03:13PM (#41141698)

It's always looked to me like from a first approximation, people just do whatever they want and come up with justifications. The smarter they are, the more elaborate the justification. I doubt I'm above it.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by dmkolobov on Friday August 02, 2024 @03:38PM (#41141916)

Right. I would argue that organized religion provides(provided?) a guided framework of accountability, transparency, and acceptance for your "justifications" amongst your community. In a vacuum, these differences compound into a complete breakdown of understanding.

It's harder to call someone a "libtard" or a "troglodyte" if you have to sit next to them in a pew for the rest of your life.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by toyg on Saturday August 03, 2024 @02:08AM (#41144964)

I fail to see how being forced to confess your crimes to someone who can then informally blackmail you or your employer, for the benefit of an elected dictator-for-life living on the other side of the ocean, provides any "transparency" or "accountability" towards the community.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by trealira on Friday August 02, 2024 @05:45PM (#41142949)

I think you're right, but that developing a sense of ethics and believing those ethics and morals down to your bones will make you not want to do certain things. People without empathy don't have trouble lying to, stealing from, or committing violence against other people - but those things feel wrong to me intrinsically, because I was raised to feel empathy. But empathy is taught. Seemingly immoral things can be everyday occurrences. For example, it used to be acceptable for husbands to beat their wives up, and now it's not. Probably most people truly believe it's immoral now, unless they grew up with their father regularly beating their mother.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by silverquiet on Friday August 02, 2024 @07:49PM (#41143640)

I suspect empathy is mostly nature with some influence via nurture. Once you encounter a few genuine psychopaths who aren’t particularly good at hiding it, it sure seems like it’s just something innate to them.

Certainly you can instill reverence in people - give people a challenge that involves using a cross as a hammer to complete and they’ll recoil instinctively, but I think that’s just software tapping into something more akin to firmware.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by trealira on Friday August 02, 2024 @08:04PM (#41143709)

This is just my conjecture, but I think that it's that psychopaths lack the capacity for empathy, and empathy is otherwise like a muscle in that it can be trained. I suspect this because I've grown more empathetic compared to when I was a kid, and some other people I've talked to said it was like that for them (not very scientific, I know). I remember being somewhat selfish and amoral.

I think it's a combination of the environment you grew up in, the behavior of the people you grew up with, the values you were raised with, and the education you received, and some of it is also purely self-driven. And so toddlers and little kids are like amoral sponges, since they're still developing their senses of justice, morality, and empathy.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:The Upstream Cause of the Youth Mental Health Crisis Is t... by toyg on Saturday August 03, 2024 @02:16AM (#41144979)

> an example where philosophy and ethics are discussed in a secular setting

That's what the intellectual cafes of 18th/19th century were. In a more bastardized way, that's what pubs can be today.

This said, school and "politics" have always been the main locations for such arguments - "politics", after all, was effectively built as an alternative to religious establishments to discuss matters without pesky clerics around.

[ Parent | on HN ]