News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A protein called Reelin keeps popping up in brains that r... by anovikov on Friday August 02, 2024 @08:02AM (#41138124)
Why? It will only result in more and harder dictatorship, more direct terror and fear, and even more unhappy society. Democracy works best when people are easy to manipulate through mass media. Smart people will need to be coerced by force. Maybe in fact, to a degree this is what already happening. Superior education in China makes democratic transition next to impossible.

Maybe the observation that countries with the best education tend to be authoritarian is not because "dictators are good at educating people" but other way around - because it's a natural selection and if a highly educated country tries to transition to democracy, it either ruins democracy, or education, or country itself.

Any model of governance mainly solves the problem of "how to satisfy interests of the stakeholders - i.e. the elite - without ruining things"; there are many ways to ruin things (even elite itself can bring about it's own downfall), but the one everyone fears most is when people get too angry. Democracy is a good way to shift responsibility back to people itself, thus defusing this threat. But it requires people being sufficiently dumb to bite it.

Re:A protein called Reelin keeps popping up in brains that r... by djeastm on Friday August 02, 2024 @10:44AM (#41139188)
>countries with the best education tend to be authoritarian

On what basis are you making this claim?

Re:A protein called Reelin keeps popping up in brains that r... by kybernetikos on Friday August 02, 2024 @11:12AM (#41139481)
> Democracy works best when people are easy to manipulate through mass media

This is a huge statement that seems wrong to me. Democracy works best when the population are engaged and hard to manipulate.

Also the "observation that countries with the best education are authoritarian" seems wrong to me too. The data I see has the top 10 entirely filled with democracies, with Singapore as the first nondemocracy coming in at 11th place. Check the economist democracy index, the correlation between democracy and education is imperfect but strong.

And those are arguments based on data. There are also arguments based on logic. Authoritarianism and education are fundamentally opposed, because authoritarians hate the teaching of things that disagree with their own specific viewpoint and suppress it.

Re:A protein called Reelin keeps popping up in brains that r... by ClumsyPilot on Friday August 02, 2024 @01:46PM (#41140937)
> Democracy works best when people are easy to manipulate through mass media. Smart people will need to be coerced by force.

Been there done that, it’s called Russia.

I don’t agree with your worldview, but if I was presented with the choice is between dumb, fake democracy and clever competent dictatorship, I might as well choose the latter. At least trains will run on time.

Re:A protein called Reelin keeps popping up in brains that r... by bobthepanda on Friday August 02, 2024 @02:00PM (#41141071)
The clever, competent dictatorship is quite rare, though.
Re:A protein called Reelin keeps popping up in brains that r... by dralley on Friday August 02, 2024 @02:40PM (#41141420)
And short-lived