News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by openasocket on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @03:50PM (#41122794)
Depending on what kind of approvals they gave him 10 years ago, it MIGHT be possible that doing this violates a contract. It sounds like they had some kind of understanding when they gave him access that he had some sort of informal approval. Even if nothing was signed, that still forms a contract. Even if there was a formal contract or terms of service (TOS) agreement, there are certain restrictions around when and how a company can change their TOS. In particular, there's often requirements about how much advance notice has to be given if the terms of service change.

It sounds like the monetary stakes are pretty small, but depending on the author's desire, it might be worth doing some research and potentially going to small claims court and claiming damages for those customers that requested refunds.

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by WoodenChair on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @04:42PM (#41123222)
> It sounds like the monetary stakes are pretty small, but depending on the author's desire, it might be worth doing some research and potentially going to small claims court and claiming damages for those customers that requested refunds.

Yes, the monetary stakes are too small for it to be worth it for me to pursue. I could probably dig up some old emails from 10+ years ago but it just wouldn't be worth it. Exposing this kind of bad behavior (4-days notice!) is enough.

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by Aurornis on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @04:54PM (#41123356)
> Depending on what kind of approvals they gave him 10 years ago, it MIGHT be possible that doing this violates a contract.

What contract? He never entered into a contract or even exchanged consideration with Yelp for the API as far as I can tell.

Getting a green light via e-mail to use a free service is not a binding contract and does not come with any obligations.

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by openasocket on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @06:22PM (#41124130)
It sounds like he requested API access in order to make a native Mac application for Yelp. The specifics matter a lot here, but “if you develop a native Mac application for Yelp, we’ll give you free API access” sounds a lot like consideration. That could be completely false based on exactly how that went down, of course.
Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by Aurornis on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @06:57PM (#41124427)
> but “if you develop a native Mac application for Yelp, we’ll give you free API access” sounds a lot like consideration.

He was using a free API that anyone could sign up for.

They did not exchange anything with him. Developing an app to use someone's free API is not an exchange of consideration.

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by WoodenChair on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @07:31PM (#41124648)
> Developing an app to use someone's free API is not an exchange of consideration.

I would never pursue anything further over this app that had about $2,000 of revenue over 10 years. That said, for the record there was consideration.

I had to go through an official approval process that required providing evidence of the app's functionality and a few emails back and forth. I think I actually sent them a prototype of it. And based on that process they decided how many daily API calls to give me. A normal free user did not receive 25,000 API calls per day. I believe if you didn't go through approval back then you got something like 1,000 per month. So there was a consideration process on their part and a determination to green light my use case.

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by wizzwizz4 on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @07:52PM (#41124781)
Ah, that's not what consideration means in contract law. Consideration means something is exchanged for something else. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consideration_in_English_law)

You could argue that the indefinite API access was in exchange for writing the app (service for service), but if this were me, I probably wouldn't bother. Maybe I'd write an adversarial-interoperability backend to replace the API, or open-source the app to allow other interested parties to do so. Or maybe I'd just say "It was a nice run", and let it die.

If you care enough to send a polite email, you could say that Yelp has a prior agreement, you'd appreciate them not reneging, and if they do, you'd appreciate compensation for your labour (minus, of course, the money you made from the software). Probably won't go anywhere, but…

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by WoodenChair on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @08:04PM (#41124852)
Oh thank you for that clarification. That's very interesting, but of course it is not worth it to me to pursue for the reasons mentioned in the post and the comments here on HN.
Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by openasocket on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @08:22PM (#41124973)
Yeah I think the only option in which this would make sense for you to peruse legal action is in small claims court for however much you had to pay in refunds. It’s fairly easy to do that pro se (representing yourself). And often companies are motivated to negotiate if they are sued in small claims, because just sending a lawyer to represent them would cost as much, if not more than just paying the damages. Obviously this depends a lot of jurisdiction and the specifics.

But at that point it’s not a question of cost, it’s a question of how much of your time and headache you want to spend. So yeah, probably not worth it

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by ynx on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @11:00PM (#41125782)
something of value*

granting API access in excess of the free tier would most likely constitute something of value, but yeah - probably wouldn't bother, it would be expensive to pursue and not worth it.

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by wizzwizz4 on Thursday August 01, 2024 @07:11AM (#41127969)
Officially, yes, something of value. In practice, just something.

> To my mind the acquiring and delivering of the [used chocolate bar] wrappers was certainly part of the consideration in these cases, and I see no good reason for drawing a distinction between these and other cases. — Lord Reid

> It is said that when received the wrappers are of no value to Nestlé’s. This I would have thought irrelevant. A contracting party can stipulate for what consideration he chooses. A peppercorn does not cease to be good consideration if it is established that the promisee does not like pepper and will throw away the corn. — Lord Somervell of Harrow

https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1959/1.html

Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by umanwizard on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @07:23PM (#41124599)
I would be amazed if it’s somehow possible for a company to implicitly commit themselves to giving you API access forever without a formal contract.
Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by openasocket on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @07:39PM (#41124704)
Not forever, no. But usually with any sort of contract, when one side wants to break or alter the contract they have to give the other side adequate notice. In certain circumstances a contract can eliminate such a requirement, and the definition of “adequate” would vary a lot based on specifics, but that is very much a possibility in this case.
Re:After 10 Years, Yelp Gave My App 4 Days by ynx on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @11:04PM (#41125795)
What's needed to form a contract is an offer, acceptance, and consideration - if an offer was made and accepted and something of value was exchanged, and there wasn't confusion about the terms (after 10 years, there wouldn't be), that's good enough for a contract to have legal force.