Re:The Economic News Isn't All Bleak
by jerf on Saturday December 27, 2008 @01:56PM
(#411225)
Actually, rather than a false choice fallacy, my real point is that no matter how prepared you are, you can always hypothesize a situation for which your preparation is insufficient. Concluding that therefore, any given action (in this case, saving dollars) is a bad idea because it "might not be enough" is an invalid argument. One must argue about probabilities. I personally do not rate a hyperinflation of the US dollar without massive upheaval a very strong probability; your other cited examples weren't the foundation of the global economy. (I rate it much lower than either no hyperinflation, or hyperinflation with massive upheaval. The people stealing your goods in the massive upheaval case is likely to be the government, so merely "a gun" won't cut it.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
>>I personally do not rate a hyperinflation of the US dollar without massive upheaval a very strong probability; your other cited examples weren't the foundation of the global economy.
Well, I cited at lest some foundation to my argument - there were numberous cases where serious devaluation did not coincide with too much social disorder. I don't see how being "the foundation of global economy" makes Americans any more likely to riot and pillage. The only cases I can think of this happening in developed countries is an outright revolution, for which there does not seem to be basis in US right now.
You're quite right to worry about government doing the pillaging though. While probability is low, the consequences would be disastorous and if one is hedging their bets might as well include this possibility. Hence why I suggested keeping your goods abroad - that way you are diversified across two political systems.