Sounds like the role is more than just as a developer, but someone who desirably is a long term part of the business and its growth.
I think the parameters slightly change for this type of position. In your shoes I would pitch the vision & culture you're trying to nurture as much as the technical challenges and career advancement that would come out of it.
As I mentioned in another comment, I'd love to have someone that takes ownership (literally and figuratively) for the project.
That's good advice about pitching the vision and culture - I'll do that for sure.
That said, the only thing I'd really advise against are things like oDesk and their ilk. You might find good talent there, and I know people have had good success, but in every success story I hear, they all start with "Well, I had to fire 8 guys before I found this one."
As for hiring, there are of course the monthly "Looking to hire / Looking for freelancer" threads on here that are generally gold for getting qualified candidates.
Where are you located? Do you need your person to be close? Are you in a tech hub (like SF, NYC, vs. say, Des Moines [I assume?]) If so, craigslist might work as a way to get the resumes to start coming in.
Ideally, you'd want to look for someone with previous startup experience.
Uhhh, there's more, but my mind just blanked. I'll come back as I think of anything else relevant.
Good to know about oDesk and the like.
I am located in Bend, Oregon but moving (back) to the Bay Area very soon. So I will obviously be in a developer-rich area. (My friend/developer is located in SF.)
Thanks for your advice - it's much appreciated.
Good idea.
(I would hire my previous developer again but he recently had a kid and started an intense full time job. So he's out.)
Customer audience is sports-related - coaches in particular.
Customer facing insofar that we'll likely want to raise some money and I'd like this person involved in that process. But not necessarily to attend directly to customer inquiries.
In my mind, a reduced rate + equity would be ideal. I don't want anyone going hungry during the ramping up process but at the same time I'd like them to take ownership and be emotionally invested in the project.
I am willing to consider all of options for the right person.