News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by langsoul-com on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @11:06PM (#41116100)
The illusion of self driving is super dangerous.

People completely check out, like this person, playing on their phone. And then an avoidable accident happens, this one being fatal.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by beaglesss on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @11:19PM (#41116144)
I realize commerical aviation is a bit of an exception but I'm not sure humans are compatible with not checking out with autopilot.

Might be better to have the autopilot as the copilot and not the other way around.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by rsynnott on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @02:52AM (#41116922)
In practice a certain amount of checking out on aircraft autopilot is arguably tolerable; the operator generally has _some_ time to react to something happening. Cars aren’t like that.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by Grimblewald on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @02:56AM (#41116941)
Aviation is an exception because everything has autopilot, and so it is MUCH easier to predict what others on the road are doing. If every car is self driving and can communicate, then things like random braking etc aren't an issue, cars can communicate stuff like this in advance.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by sfn42 on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @04:23AM (#41117318)
Planes also have the advantage of not having to deal with pedestrians, bicyclists and other moving obstacles that will never be part of this hypothetical network.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by watwut on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @10:48AM (#41119686)
Airspace is basically empty compared to roads.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by nradov on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @11:08AM (#41119888)
There are always going to be objects on the road that aren't "self driving" and can't communicate. Like pedestrians and cyclists.

Only a subset of aircraft have autopilots, and many autopilots have very limited functionality. You can't just set a destination airport and go to sleep. The pilot is actively flying the aircraft at all times, even if they're not directly actuating the flight controls.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by bcrl on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @04:31PM (#41123128)
Telsas can't even avoid hitting stopped emergency vehicles, so I'm not sure how communication between vehicles is going to solve their problems.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by aaomidi on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @04:40PM (#41123198)
Also aviation is…not easy to get into. There’s so much work and effort and two party control for all commercial flights.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by Ekaros on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @03:00AM (#41116954)
Marine traffic and aviation are very different environments from where cars operate. You do have lot more reaction time, lot less traffic and hazards are often static and visible long way away. And in scenarios where they are not, well I hope lot less blind trust is put in.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by vdqtp3 on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @03:22AM (#41117060)
Commercial aviation is a little different in that on an IFR flight plan (which encompasses pretty much the whole time the autopilot is active), ATC is maintaining a 3 mile lateral bubble around the aircraft, making sure that there are no conflicts. So even though the pilot may not be as engaged in see-and-avoid behavior (which is the primary responsibility during VFR), there should be no risk of mid-air collision.

Aviation practices are very much about ensuring that there are extra layers of protection that should all prevent an accident, that even if one fails the others continue to maintain safety. ATC, autopilot, pilot, TCAS, etc. Contrast this with automotive practices, which seem to be about achieving the minimum amount of safety possible.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by squarefoot on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @06:00AM (#41117738)
> I realize commerical aviation is a bit of an exception

If flying in free air had the same number of variables as driving on oddly shaped roads filled with oddly shaped vehicles and obstacles and the occasional people crossing where they shouldn't, we'd have an air crash every hour. A flock of pigeons usually isn't fatal for an airplane engine, now imagine flying surrounded by people testing their new jet backpack. I'm 100% convinced we'll send someone to Mars a lot before we'll have safe self driving vehicles.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by 0xfaded on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @11:21PM (#41116151)
First I agree the driver shouldn't have been on their phone no matter what.

I think before passing judgement though, I would like to know how a human would have performed. Aviation investigations often recreate scenarios in a simulator and then have other pilots fly them. I'd imagine something similar could be done for cars.

FSD is pretty good at motorcycle detection and has the advantage of cameras looking in all directions.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by Log_out_ on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @01:45AM (#41116648)
But.. It has been here for many years, overpromising, under delivering at full price. And all it did was ride the coat tails of the tonystark "still relevant"fantasy of men everywhere. No,the world is already carved up, nobody gets a slice by wits alone unless already owing a bone. Meanwhile waymo quietly walked the walk..

No buts,no ifs,just a stif

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by kanbara on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @03:51AM (#41117171)
FSD is terrible and shouldn’t be road legal. The FSD caused the accident regardless of how a human looking at the road would’ve performed.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by TSP00N3 on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @04:16AM (#41117290)
2024 Q1: “we recorded one crash for every 7.63 million miles driven in which drivers were using Autopilot technology. For drivers who were not using Autopilot technology, we recorded one crash for every 955,000 miles driven. By comparison, the most recent data available from NHTSA and FHWA (from 2022) shows that in the United States, there was an automobile crash approximately every 670,000 miles.” [0]

And for further info that includes a comparison to Waymo see [1].

Doesn’t seem right to call something that is 10x safer “terrible”, but maybe you have different metrics you are looking at.

[0] https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-releases-vehicle-safety-repo... [1] https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2024/07/tesla-autopilot-fsd-an...

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @04:35AM (#41117374)
> that is 10x safer “terrible”, but maybe you have different metrics you are looking at.

Of maybe your “metrics” are just slightly dishonest?

Presumably you can only use FSD under conditions where accidents are already significantly less likely to happen (per mile driven) like freeways etc?

Which makes this an apples to oranges comparison.

Turning “FSD” off just before an accident is likely to happen without necessarily giving enough time for the driver to react would also be very helpful (although I’m not sure how the cases would be recorded specifically )

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by FireBeyond on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @11:33AM (#41120103)
> Doesn’t seem right to call something that is 10x safer “terrible”, but maybe you have different metrics you are looking at.

Quick question: are there roads or conditions Autopilot doesn't do well on, so can't or won't be activated?

I don't see Autopilot working well in a bitter New England winter storm at night. Or a torrential Florida downpour.

That's why those metrics suck. And Tesla knows. They compare "all drivers, all conditions" to the "idealist, best case subset of miles driven by Autopilot".

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by pengaru on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @11:52AM (#41120274)
Lies, damn lies, and statistics.
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by YeGoblynQueenne on Thursday August 01, 2024 @06:31AM (#41127739)
>> Doesn’t seem right to call something that is 10x safer “terrible”, but maybe you have different metrics you are looking at.

Check out the guidelines:

Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by RaftPeople on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @10:47AM (#41119678)
> I would like to know how a human would have performed

Well, his vehicle was the only one on that busy highway that afternoon that "lurched forward while accelerating" and crashed into the motorcycle in front of him, so I think we have the answer to your question.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by dmazzoni on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @03:21PM (#41122481)
I think it'd also be worth comparing it to cars that have more basic collision-avoidance.

I don't expect Tesla's FSD to be perfect. But I do expect it to not be worse than the simple and effective collision avoidance that nearly all new cars have.

Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by nm-f on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @05:54AM (#41117709)
Exactly, IMO the point of autopilot is to be a passenger in your own car with a guarantee that it won't cause and accident. If you have to be ready to take over, then what's the point?
Re:Tesla in Seattle-area crash that killed motorcyclist was ... by Chyzwar on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @10:32AM (#41119523)
What is dangerous is selling FSD for 10k $ without lidar.