Re:New study simulates gravitational waves from failing warp...
by Joker_vD on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @03:41PM
(#41113347)
Um, sorry, how does that experiment prove anything quantum? It's explained entirely by Malus' law of I = I0 * cos^2(alpha) which has an entirely classical, simple wave-theoretical explanation (even if Malus himself was an emissionist and derived his law by introducing transversal asymmetry in the light corpuscles).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New study simulates gravitational waves from failing warp...
by K0balt on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @06:38PM
(#41114832)
Malus’s law does indeed describe the amplitudes of the resulting light, but it does not say “why”, only how. In the same way that Newtonian physics assumes gravity but fails to explain its existence.
For more in depth look at this there is a 1995 paper by K Wódkiewicz contrasting the corpuscular formula with the quantum explanation IIRC.
Obviously, despite its explanatory power, we know that QM is incomplete so YMMV, but I’ll take QM over light corpuscles, until something better comes along.
Re:New study simulates gravitational waves from failing warp...
by Joker_vD on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @06:45AM
(#41117966)
> I’ll take QM over light corpuscles
Having light corpuscles that have poles and can experience fits of easy transmission/reflection is not much mathematically different from having photons with spins and wave phases, to be fair.
And Malus' original justification of his law straightforwardly carries over to the photons.