News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grothendieck on Scientism, the New Universal Church [pdf] by jessriedel on Monday July 29, 2024 @01:21PM (#41102030)
It's poetic language, and arguably unnecessarily inflammatory, but it's not the main thesis of the essay. Specifically: If you identified a key distinction between religion and scientism that we all agreed was "required" by any good definition of religion but wasn't found in scientism (say, an afterlife, or a story for why bad things happen to good people), that wouldn't much affect the validity of the essay.
Re:Grothendieck on Scientism, the New Universal Church [pdf] by bazoom42 on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @07:52AM (#41108177)
If you remove the analogy to religion I don’t see how any substance remains. For example the essay present subject experts as problematic through the analogy to high priests. But if you remove this analogy it is just common sense that someone who have studied a subject knows more than someone who hasn’t.

I mean a carpenter knows more about carpentry than a random person - how is that controversial or problematic? But lets call carpenters high priests thereby implying carpentry expertise is suspect. If you try to lecture a seasoned carpenter about carpentry they would probly also call you an idiot in more or less polite words. I guess that just proves how carpenters are like high priests jaleously guarding their status?

Re:Grothendieck on Scientism, the New Universal Church [pdf] by jessriedel on Thursday August 01, 2024 @12:24AM (#41126144)
I strongly disagree with your reading of this essay.