News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by maratd on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:19PM (#4108518)
I don't want civilian police forces using military equipment for any reason. It's really that simple.

Rand Paul gets it.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tzs on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:31PM (#4108568)
Drones are no more military equipment than are guns, cars, and radios. All of those are equipment that is used both by civilians and by the military.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by maratd on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @06:03PM (#4108704)
If your local police force started chasing after people using tanks, then well, tanks would no longer be military equipment.

Military equipment is any equipment that is predominantly used by the military and not so much by anybody else.

Drones are primarily used by the military. They are military equipment. If they start getting used by local police forces left and right, well, they would no longer be military equipment. And that would be unfortunate.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tptacek on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @06:09PM (#4108732)
"Drone" is just a colloquialism for "unmanned aircraft".

"Tank" is a word that means "armored vehicle, likely fitted with heavy arms".

So the problem with your comments here are simple as far as I can tell:

There is a nationwide problem of police forces using tanks as part of SWAT operations, and of manufacturers of what are effectively tanks starting to tailor products to police forces. This militarization of our police forces is a real problem and worth talking about.

But wow do you ever muddy the waters when you suggest that a straightforward technological advance --- small, remote-controlled unmanned aircraft --- must clearly be "military" because its first widely-known use was by the military.

There are already civilian drones. Drones were used during Fukushima to monitor radiation above the burning reactors. Energy companies apparently use them to monitor marine mammals in offshore drilling.

You are on extraordinarily shaky ground when you attempt to paint "law enforcement UAVs" with the "hellfire missile" brush. I think you should let this point go.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by Retric on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @06:18PM (#4108767)
SWAT (special weapons and tactics) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SWAT is specifically a group of police officers trained to use military weapons and tactics. They do use APC's (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armoured_personnel_carrier) but don't use 'tanks' because they don't fight people in armored vehicles.

PS: What separates tanks from APC's tank's are designed to be artillery pieces (aka Cannon) which can move while protecting their gun crew. Where an APC's goal is to transport infantry. It may have some built in armaments but it's more effective for people to get out when the fighting starts. This compares to a howitzer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRF1 which is designed to be far enough from enemy lines that while it may be mobile it does not need to protect it's crew.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by ekianjo on Thursday June 14, 2012 @04:50AM (#4110393)
Then please allow civilian use of drones as well. Without any restrictions. And let us send drones to track governors, senators, public figures, to see how they feel about being watched.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by shrikant on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:43PM (#4108625)
Good thing they don't use the Internet or GPS then.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by maratd on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:49PM (#4108658)
It's unfortunate that they do and I would support Mr Paul if he tried to stop that as well.

The FBI is actively working on lobbying for backdoors into every major communications service, including the social networks.

http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/05/fbi-seeks-internet-...

They are also using GPS to spy on random people of interest without warrants.

http://www.itworld.com/it-managementstrategy/253374/3000-war...

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tptacek on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:54PM (#4108674)
As the first sentence of that GPS link points out, the practice of using GPS trackers as a substitute for human agents following cars (which obviously doesn't require a warrant) was halted by the Supreme Court, which stated that the FBI needs a warrant to attach a GPS device to someone's car, not that they are forbidden from using GPS.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by defen on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @07:39PM (#4109061)
GPS tracking was struck down on extremely narrow technical grounds - without a warrant the police do not have the right to trespass upon your vehicle (attach a GPS tracker). They deliberately did not rule upon the rightness or wrongness of tracking someone's public travel without a warrant. Since there will be no physical trespass when airborne drones are tracking our cars, that Supreme Court ruling isn't really relevant.

In my opinion, tracking someone automatically (either via GPS or drone), as opposed to having an actual person follow them, is sufficiently different in terms of cost that it becomes a qualitatively different phenomenon.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by droithomme on Thursday June 14, 2012 @12:41AM (#4109798)
And from the description of the bill:

> The Preserving Freedom from Unwarranted Surveillance Act would require the government to get a warrant before using aerial drones to surveil U.S. citizens.

It doesn't ban drones. It bans their use for police surveillance without a warrant based on probable cause. A lot of people seem to be confused about this issue.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by baddox on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @08:27PM (#4109211)
I must be military too, because I use the Internet and GPS.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by TeMPOraL on Thursday June 14, 2012 @05:06AM (#4110433)
On your feet soldier! Why are you on the Internet, when the missiles are coming?!
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tsotha on Thursday June 14, 2012 @01:30AM (#4109952)
How are drones different than the helicopters police forces already use?
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by ekianjo on Thursday June 14, 2012 @04:52AM (#4110398)
Cheaper. Can be mass-produced. Autonomous. No need for permanent man-operation.

It lowers the technical barrier for surveillance of a large population significantly. Therefore, that's what we call a groundbreaking technology.

that's what's different.

"How is the Internet fundamentally different than the telegraph? " "How is a ITBM different from artillery?" "How is the car different from a carriage?"

You can use that kind of question for every technological advances. Obviously every major step changes behaviors significantly.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tsotha on Thursday June 14, 2012 @12:09PM (#4111997)
I meant "how are drones different from a legal perspective?"
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by maratd on Thursday June 14, 2012 @12:21PM (#4112068)
They're not. That's why we're talking about passing a law that makes them different.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tsotha on Thursday June 14, 2012 @03:04PM (#4112970)
So why not pass a law forbidding police departments from using helicopters?
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by maratd on Thursday June 14, 2012 @04:46PM (#4113437)
Because helicopters are already widely used, drones are not. Yet. Because a helicopter costs millions of dollars. A drone doesn't. A helicopter must be flown by a person. Drones can be automated. Are you starting to get the picture? 1 helicopter = 100 drones. Go read 1981 by Orwell. You'll begin to understand the concept of something being Orwellian.
Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tsotha on Thursday June 14, 2012 @06:09PM (#4113783)
>Because helicopters are already widely used, drones are not. Yet.

So what?

>Because a helicopter costs millions of dollars.

Drones that provide enough persistence for surveillance aren't anywhere near that cheap. DHS paid $180m for ten of them, making them far more expensive than the kind of helicopters police departments use.

>A helicopter must be flown by a person. Drones can be automated.

Sort of. The FAA is still going to require an operator in case there's some kind of air traffic situation. And someone still has to sort through whatever data the drone is providing, something that isn't automated.

>Are you starting to get the picture? 1 helicopter = 100 drones. Go read 1981 by Orwell. You'll begin to understand the concept of something being Orwellian.

Yeah, I get the picture. This is mostly hyperventilating. The statement you can buy and operate 100 drones for the cost of one helicopter displays a complete disconnect from reality. You need to do a little reading up on what kinds of capabilities drones offer at what cost.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by maratd on Thursday June 14, 2012 @09:52PM (#4114541)
> DHS paid $180m for ten of them

Errr ... those are Predators. Literally the military model. You know, the ones that can shoot missiles and stuff.

Nobody is talking about that.

I can stick a battery powered WiFi cam on a model airplane and get remote surveillance that doesn't cost 18 million. This is the same issue as plastering cameras at every intersection.

Guess what? My town just did that. They have cameras on almost every intersection. That's sick.

Wake up.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by tsotha on Friday June 15, 2012 @01:53PM (#4117745)
>I can stick a battery powered WiFi cam on a model airplane and get remote surveillance that doesn't cost 18 million.

Sure, you can. And you'll get what you pay for in terms of useful images. Far from your Orwellian fantasy, your little plane will only be in the sky for a few minutes, meaning you can't use it for surveillance.

>Guess what? My town just did that. They have cameras on almost every intersection. That's sick.

That's a totally different issue, and one on which we agree. What they've done in the UK is a travesty, and I don't want to see it where I live.

>Wake up.

Oh, I see. The only reason I wouldn't agree with you is because I'm sleeping. Idiot.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by rprasad on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @07:32PM (#4109043)
So you are opposed to police using bulletproof vests, GPS (in their cars, not to track people), and the internet (including websites for their agencies)?

Almost all of the equipment used by police today was once military equipment. Some of it still is.

Re:Sen. Paul proposes bill protecting Americans from drone s... by mjwalshe on Thursday June 14, 2012 @05:00AM (#4110412)
um so why do American Police need hand guns with more powerful rounds than SF Operators (Delta, DEvGuru the SAS etc) do them.

I bet Bonnie and Clyde wish that the Police where banned from having "Milatery weapons" as it was the full auto BAR's that did for them back in the 30's