News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit bans The Atlantic, Businessweek, others in major a... by danso on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:19PM (#4108514)
Isn't this heavy-handed banning approach pretty much a tacit admission that the voting algorithm is broken? Why couldn't this spamming be prevented through pattern algorithms/frequency analysis and...this is what I thought Reddit aspired to...democracy? If a lot of articles from a source are voted up by a diverse group of users, then maybe it's because the source is good?

The worst part of this is how this countermeasure reeks of the fallacy of ad hominem: who cares who the submitter is and how he/she personally benefits...as long as the content is good?

Re:Reddit bans The Atlantic, Businessweek, others in major a... by freshhawk on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @06:49PM (#4108878)
> The worst part of this is how this countermeasure reeks of the fallacy of ad hominem: who cares who the submitter is and how he/she personally benefits...as long as the content is good?

Well, the easiest answer to that is that one of the best ways to separate the good content from the bad algorithmically is to look at the submitter behavior. Saying "as long as the content is good" glosses over the practicalities of actually measuring that.

Re:Reddit bans The Atlantic, Businessweek, others in major a... by nooneelse on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:29PM (#4108558)
Another possibility would be prominently marking submissions from spammers. And/or all links to sites that are proven spammers. Let the users/communities have more information to cogitate with when deciding if the content is worth voting up.
Re:Reddit bans The Atlantic, Businessweek, others in major a... by cpunks on Thursday June 14, 2012 @06:26AM (#4110646)
reddit don't aspire to democracy. Note that the set of links on the default page aren't the most popular or up-voted; they are from a pre-selected set of reddits that e.g. include atheism but not e.g. hinduism. This gives a feedback loop -- Hindus see offensive hate speech, and go away. Atheists see an accepting community, and more come in. The types of content and community you see there is clearly engineered -- I think most incidentally, and a little intentionally.