News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grothendieck on Scientism, the New Universal Church [pdf] by Terr_ on Friday July 26, 2024 @07:08PM (#41083125)
There's also an overlooked distinction between a religion versus a religious belief.

For example, "the sun is an egg of the great pillbug that created the universe" is a religious belief, but it would be quite a stretch to call it a religion.

I think the distinction is particularly important because it underlies how a lot of people talk past each other when it comes to atheism, since "zero gods have ever existed" is also a religious belief without being a religion.

Re:Grothendieck on Scientism, the New Universal Church [pdf] by bazoom42 on Saturday July 27, 2024 @07:38AM (#41085906)
I agree religion is much more than beliefs. Rituals, community, traditions etc is at least as signifiant as beliefs.

But by what criteria is “zero gods exist” a religious belief compared to say “phlogiston does not exist”?

Re:Grothendieck on Scientism, the New Universal Church [pdf] by Terr_ on Saturday July 27, 2024 @05:32PM (#41089480)
Well, flip it around, by what criteria was the positive "phlogiston exists" a religious belief to start with?

For almost any positive statement about religious topics or implications, the negated version remains also about religious topics or implications.

"Bread doesn't exist" is still a belief about the concept of bread.

Re:Grothendieck on Scientism, the New Universal Church [pdf] by bazoom42 on Monday July 29, 2024 @07:14AM (#41099519)
So if some religion claims sunspots does not exist, it would make the existence of sunspots a religious belief?