Re:Is Cultivated Meat for Real?
by ben_w on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:25PM
(#41082420)
> As for wanting to reduce suffering, natural, pasture raised humane farming can achieve that.
Not on the scale of demand.
> Humans controlled animal populations and thinned herds for thousands of years in humane ways before the advent of factory farming, we just need to dial back the clock on our mechanized monstrosity.
1) What we did to animals was never humane. There's a reason that it is bad when humans get treated "like animals".
For one, the traditional methods of slaughter don't involve a bolt gun to stun them, so by going back to the old ways we go from saying "who is to blame if the bolt gun doesn't stun them before slaughter?" to "what bolt gun?" and them being exsanguinated starting while conscious.
2) The mechanised monstrosity is the result of all the people who want to eat meat and for that meat to be cheap.
If you want to enforce idilic meadows for all cows, and that they only get to be turned into food when they die of natural causes, be prepared for riots — "Qu'ils mangent de la brioche" style, because that's expensive and a lot of people (e.g. in the UK) are struggling to pay rent and use food banks already.
May also need to severely reduce the human population to achieve that due to lack of suitable land, given how many cattle are fed crops grow elsewhere. Can't tell how you feel about that, I've seen people go both ways in these kinds of arguments — even though it seems inconsistent to call for a reduction of human population while being not OK with a reduction of the livestock population.
Also:
> The only way to not have suffering is to not have life
Not on the scale of demand.
> Humans controlled animal populations and thinned herds for thousands of years in humane ways before the advent of factory farming, we just need to dial back the clock on our mechanized monstrosity.
1) What we did to animals was never humane. There's a reason that it is bad when humans get treated "like animals".
For one, the traditional methods of slaughter don't involve a bolt gun to stun them, so by going back to the old ways we go from saying "who is to blame if the bolt gun doesn't stun them before slaughter?" to "what bolt gun?" and them being exsanguinated starting while conscious.
2) The mechanised monstrosity is the result of all the people who want to eat meat and for that meat to be cheap.
If you want to enforce idilic meadows for all cows, and that they only get to be turned into food when they die of natural causes, be prepared for riots — "Qu'ils mangent de la brioche" style, because that's expensive and a lot of people (e.g. in the UK) are struggling to pay rent and use food banks already.
May also need to severely reduce the human population to achieve that due to lack of suitable land, given how many cattle are fed crops grow elsewhere. Can't tell how you feel about that, I've seen people go both ways in these kinds of arguments — even though it seems inconsistent to call for a reduction of human population while being not OK with a reduction of the livestock population.
Also:
> The only way to not have suffering is to not have life
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duḥkha