Re:Is Cultivated Meat for Real?
by ben_w on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:13PM
(#41082321)
> Suffering is literally foundational to life friend, you can't end it.
Says who?
In a counterfactual world where those things were done to a group of humans, from puberty to menopause, one could say exactly the same as your comment.
And yet, human chattel slavery is illegal, and anyone attempting what I've just described would be prosecuted for crimes against humanity and/or genocide — a newspaper or historical report saying a group of people "were treated like animals" is a sign of something horrific, and if someone is known as "a butcher" because of what they did to humans then we don't wave it away as "suffering is literally foundational to life".
And we don't like it when other things eat us, be the other bacteria or shark. Instead, we make the world safe for us… because we don't accept "suffering is foundational" when it is us doing the suffering.
Even in a counterfactual world where humans really did need to consume flesh — we know we don't, biologically, need to consume the flesh of others — the subject of this entire thread is growing meat in a vat, just the flesh without a mind to suffer with it. Other people are doing similar things for dairy.
Also: if you really think that "suffering is literally fundamental" is a good argument, you shouldn't have any problem with humans being forced to, as you said previously, toil away in artificial light in a giant industrial facility to make their food.
> The vegan utopia is a dead planet.
Says who?
There was a time on this world when all life was photovore or chemovore. Predation is a strategy, but one of evolution not of engineering. Predation is the "defect" strategy in the iterated prisoner's dilemma.
You wrote previously about diversity: this world has about 1.5 billion cows. This displaced all the other flora and fauna that used to exist in the same places. This is a very real loss of (bio)diversity, directly caused by what you think is giving you (dietary) diversity.
Says who?
In a counterfactual world where those things were done to a group of humans, from puberty to menopause, one could say exactly the same as your comment.
And yet, human chattel slavery is illegal, and anyone attempting what I've just described would be prosecuted for crimes against humanity and/or genocide — a newspaper or historical report saying a group of people "were treated like animals" is a sign of something horrific, and if someone is known as "a butcher" because of what they did to humans then we don't wave it away as "suffering is literally foundational to life".
And we don't like it when other things eat us, be the other bacteria or shark. Instead, we make the world safe for us… because we don't accept "suffering is foundational" when it is us doing the suffering.
Even in a counterfactual world where humans really did need to consume flesh — we know we don't, biologically, need to consume the flesh of others — the subject of this entire thread is growing meat in a vat, just the flesh without a mind to suffer with it. Other people are doing similar things for dairy.
Also: if you really think that "suffering is literally fundamental" is a good argument, you shouldn't have any problem with humans being forced to, as you said previously, toil away in artificial light in a giant industrial facility to make their food.
> The vegan utopia is a dead planet.
Says who?
There was a time on this world when all life was photovore or chemovore. Predation is a strategy, but one of evolution not of engineering. Predation is the "defect" strategy in the iterated prisoner's dilemma.
You wrote previously about diversity: this world has about 1.5 billion cows. This displaced all the other flora and fauna that used to exist in the same places. This is a very real loss of (bio)diversity, directly caused by what you think is giving you (dietary) diversity.