News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by autoexec on Thursday July 25, 2024 @01:08PM (#41070963)
> I have never experienced or heard of a doctor deceiving or lying in real life.

Meet Dr. Stella Immanuel who tells her patients that medications are made from alien DNA and that their illnesses are caused by demon sperm. In the USA she gets to keep her medical license/practice. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stella_Immanuel)

See also: every doctor that accepted bribes from Purdue Pharma in exchange for knowingly prescribing excessive amounts of opioids to people who never needed them.

Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by s1artibartfast on Thursday July 25, 2024 @03:01PM (#41072154)
I included real life as an intentional qualifier. I know that quacks, grifters, and criminals exist.

The fact that they exist doesn't bother me. Some will always exist. What matters is how common it is and what the average experience is.

I don't think most doctors treat their patients the same as Stella Immanuel. Same for the two doctors that perdue was convicted of bribing

Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by autoexec on Thursday July 25, 2024 @03:18PM (#41072328)
Half of all doctors in the US accept money or gifts from drug and device companies. (https://www.statnews.com/2020/12/04/drug-companies-payments-...)
Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by s1artibartfast on Thursday July 25, 2024 @04:03PM (#41072767)
I actually really liked that article and how it at least tried to present both sides. However, I tend to agree with the opposing side, but think there are some edge cases that could be improved. I have spent my career working in drug and device development so I probably have a more nuanced view informed by my experience. I have payed millions to doctors, and think my actions are justified.

One thing that the article touched on that I like is the role of non-industry associations, which I think could do a lot more to spread information. However, there's no one that will pay them to do it.

Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by autoexec on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:17PM (#41073975)
> I have payed millions to doctors, and think my actions are justified.

You aren't at all worried that paying those doctors will result in them prescribing something to a patient when they might not have otherwise or influence their choice for one option over another? I'm not talking about the education or awareness a doctor might get, purely the influence of the money/benefits and perhaps their hope to get more of the same from you later.

Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by s1artibartfast on Thursday July 25, 2024 @07:30PM (#41074535)
The vast majority of the payments are either education or payment for services rendered, like the article mentions.

At a high level, companies actually think their products have value to patients and want doctors to know about what it can do. It is virtually impossible to decouple knowledge sharing from influence. The point of knowledge sharing is to impact choice and behavior.

On the services front, If I want to hire a doctor to fly across the country and do Brian surgery on a pig or cadaver, I expect to have to pay them. Similarly, if they are running a clinical trial, I expect to fly them to the surgical training and feed them, and pay for their time.

>purely the influence of the money/benefits and perhaps their hope to get more of the same from you later.

Direct kickbacks for prescriptions are a thing of the past. It is pretty hard to come up with a situation where future benefits is conditional on the behavior. Like, I suppose you wouldn't invite a doctor that doesnt use your product to give feedback on it or be part of a clinical trial, but that is a niche feedback to worry about.

Lastly, articles like are very misleading when it comes to the details. In their reference for $2B in payments [1], includes things like Royalties.

>The greatest proportion (27.3%) of value was from royalty or license payments (≈$484 million of $1.8 billion) followed by service fees (26.6%), such as faculty lectures ($472 million of $1.8 billion).

If they are claiming paying royalty or license payments for inventions (like developing a hip implant) are a kickback, it frames the whole argument as rhetoric.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5470350/

Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by phil21 on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:20AM (#41078870)
I’ve found the “collective common knowledge” regarding pop-culture topics such as this, is much like generals preparing for the last war they fought.

Direct kickbacks were an actual problem decades ago. That has long been “solved” all the way to the typical over correction the industry is known for.

The same holds true for the opioid epidemic and folks still thinking pill mills and the medical industry as a whole are the primary way folks get hooked.

It’s fighting last decades battles that have long since moved on. The zeitgeist seems to “stick” each generation and does not seem to keep up with current reality.

Re:Taking my diabetes treatment into my own hands (2024) by s1artibartfast on Friday July 26, 2024 @06:40PM (#41082973)
yes. Conflating Perdue Pharma/OxyContin with the larger opiate epidemic is a particularly egregious example.

Perdue engaged in criminal actions, but it did not cause the epidemic. It is just a small part of the story. Deceitful labeling and aggressive marketing of OxyContin in the 90's has zero bearing on people dying from fentanyl laced weed in 2024.

I think the biggest factor in all of this misinformation is a human desire to compress the complexity of life into simple soundbite narratives that make sense.

The more emotionally charged or pressing an issue is, the greater the human desire is to think/feel like they have it all figured out. Even if that means sacrificing truth.

Humans have a compulsion to categorize and explain everything they encounter. Failure to do so is cognitively painful so anything too difficult is simplified until it "makes sense".

In my opinion, this compulsion is at the heart of all human problems, but also all of our achievements.