They're repeating propaganda about communism and socialism.
It's tiresome, really, the degree to which Americans have bought the propaganda that countries like the Soviet Union themselves spread, that they were communist, when in fact they were authoritarian dictatorships with a few very-badly-thought-out planned-economy features.
True communism has never been tried, it will work this time around…
Please then, what was it? Capitalist? Feudal? Democratic socialism? I need a clear answer..
It's obvious that "communist" policies don't entail that you have the same government as the USSR, so I think it's fair to call arguments that suggest so propaganda. It's probably meaningless to argue about whether the USSR had "true communism".
That's the problem with this type of topic. As much as I like to talk about it, there never seems to be any real talk. People pick a side and arguments be damned.
The extent of their knowledge generally extends to "communism bad" and there's no good faith in actually talking about the shitty situation we're in today.
My original answer was not even citing communism at all. I was specifically talking about worker conditions, but people seem to be unable or unwilling to have a conversation and instead degrade it and down vote.
Where are these so called experiments? I only see employee conditions getting progressively worse. If you go back long enough, we did get a few wins like weekends and some limits on hours after a lot of people died for it, but that's about it.
The last change we had was probably WFH which only affects a small portion of people and, realistically, is only being accepted because it's cheaper for companies.
>But, you are of course free to start a company doing that.
I argue nothing different than the status quo can ever succeed without deep structural change.
It's like trying to be a pacifist in the middle of a war zone. You will be killed. It doesn't mean there's anything wrong with being a pacifist, but it simply cannot work under those conditions.
The part that people seem to forget is that we chose to value profits above all else. We can also choose to change that. Even if it's extremely hard to imagine this with all the propaganda we've been bombarded with in the past century, it's possible.