I'd rather burn $50K paying on-staff marketing or agencies to work around a sub-optimal domain name. I'd rather buy my staff new MBPs (or I would have before this soldered-in RAM bull). Hell, I'd rather support my local liquor store and buy a few cases of Great Divide and several dozen wings every Friday and invite everyone over for a free gutbombing.
Bottom line, I'm not willing to use my funds to perpetuate a business model that relies on a flavor of extortion.
A developed property in SF/NY isn't like a domain name, because at some point someone invested capital to build, much as someone must invest capital to build a website that resides at a given domain name. A completely undeveloped property in the middle of SF/NY has no intrinsic value: it's value based upon what's around it (e.g., the massive developments we call a city).
If we must have a real estate comparison to a domain name, it would be this: an island, made only of sand, out in the middle of an unending ocean full of other islands made only of sand, so geographically separated as to be completely isolated from each other.
One, this ocean does not exist on earth, and if it did, the real estate business would not be built around the buying and selling of these islands of sand for the purposes of development.
This feels a bit like a straw man, I know, but I'm trying to illustrate just how untenable the comparison between squatting and real estate truly is.
More importantly you can't buy a piece of land for $10 and sell it for $50K a few years down the road.
You absolutely can. Perhaps "a few years" needs to be redefined to a decade or more, but land speculation is absolutely possible and done a lot.
It's not a matter of nobility, it's a matter of putting my money in the areas where the a) the ROI is highest with b) the highest probability of realizing that ROI.
My experience has demonstrated that forecasting the ROI on a domain name is...well, I don't want to say impossible, but the projections are difficult to compose and they've not proven to be realistic.
Now, I may just suck at projecting the annualized value of a domain name, in which case the problem is my level of suckage.
Is your objection really objective or emotional?
I frequently talk about business in terms of flying an airplane. So I meant "burning cash" as I would mean "burning fuel" in the pursuit of getting from point A to point B. Didn't mean it in the context of getting a pile of it and lighting it on fire.
I was joking about the beer and wings bit.
That goes for domain names I hold as well. I've sold several and have never charged more than what I have in them.
This is an extreme position, I realize this.