News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by jonnathanson on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @10:32AM (#4106130)
I'm actually surprised that the 4th Amendment isn't referenced more frequently in refutation to the asinine "nothing to hide" position.

"Nothing to hide" is thematically similar to the groan-inducing "Do you want the terrorists to win?" arguments against civil liberties, in favor of increased security measures, proferred and popularly supported in the mid-2000s. (Sadly, many of the legacies and artifacts of that position still persist).

The answer to any of these half-baked arguments should always begin with something along the lines of "Because we're better than that." Because we have a constitution that assumes we're good people, and that protects our civil liberties from invasion. Because these things are so fundamental to our nation's purpose that giving them up is much worse than being attacked. Giving them up threatens the very purpose of the country's founding.

Even to entertain these arguments, i.e., by trying to cite examples of areas of privacy or liberty that are negotiable, areas that aren't, and so forth, is to stoop low. It is to lose before the argument has actually begun. It is to accept the faulty premise that privacy is about hiding something -- that it is an active attempt to conceal information from the world. No, privacy isn't the action being taken. Invasion of privacy is the action. Privacy is simply a state of being, and one to which we have an inalienable right.

Privacy isn't something we opt into; it is something we don't even really consider until we are made, or compelled, or asked to opt out. "Nothing to hide" begs the question. It assumes, as a foregone premise, that privacy is an opt-in decision that we consciously undertake in defense of something (and that something is implied to be onerous or illegal). This is just fallacious logic, plain and simple.

It's unfortunate that a right to privacy wasn't inumerated directly in the constitution, but was instead defined indirectly. This is one of those areas where the founders really couldn't have known how far technology would go, and how important something like privacy -- which may have been taken for granted back then -- would become 200+ years later.

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by hcurtiss on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @03:18PM (#4107885)
You're close here, but you're missing the big picture. It's not that the constitution assumes we're good people. It's that many of the founders were suspicious of large central governments. The anti-federalists insisted upon a bill of rights as a condition to ratification. I would assert that most of the bill of rights is about protecting the ability to of the people revolt against the government:

First Amendment - freedom of speech, freedom of assembly. Ensuring that me and my buddies can get together and talk about overthrowing the government.

Second Amendment - right to bear arms. Ensuring I have the ability to inflict harm on/protect myself from government actors.

Third Amendment - right against quartering troops. Ensuring the government can't put soldiers in my house to listen to me or intimidate me.

Fourth Amendment - right against unreasonable search and seizure. The government can't come in and take my stuff unless and until I do something "wrong."

I could go on, but to my view, is all about revolution. There may be those who think we've moved to a place in society where governments like ours are benevolent and that the majority will is always right. I don't.

Maybe people think that hanging onto such rights is futile given F-16s and M1 Abrams. I think our difficulty in Afghanistan and Iraq is a pretty good refutation of that position.

Privacy is important because, without it, bad guys can make us slaves.

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by vacri on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @07:08PM (#4108956)
The second amendment talks about a well-regulated militia. That doesn't sound like it's intended to be protection against one's own government, but against invading armies.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by noblethrasher on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @07:23PM (#4109013)
I'd like to point out, for the benefit of others, that the term well-regulated simply meant 'effective' or 'in proper working order'. It did not necessarily mean that it should be controlled by the government.

Source:http://constitution.org/cons/wellregu.htm

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by vacri on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @10:49PM (#4109558)
What about the 'militia' part? Or the 'being necessary for the security of a free state' part?

The second amendment is saying 'we're not going to restrict arms, because we need a body of men to call on who know how to use arms, in order to maintain our independence', not 'fear your government, be prepared to shoot its representitives'.

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by stinky613 on Thursday June 14, 2012 @08:16AM (#4110915)
It's both. The second amendment is necessary to maintain the security of a free state against foreign invaders and against a government seeking to take the 'free' from the 'free state'.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by noblethrasher on Thursday June 14, 2012 @12:34AM (#4109780)
I am not arguing that the second amendment is a provision for overthrowing the government. I really did just want to make sure everyone knew how 'well-regulated' should be interpreted since it's easy to read it naively.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by vacri on Thursday June 14, 2012 @06:16AM (#4110624)
Fair enough, thanks for the clarification. I was reading it still in context to the parent comment.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by hcurtiss on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:36AM (#4111502)
Two points:

1. Notwithstanding that language, it's an individual right. See Heller.

2. Militias were, almost exclusively, the province Of the individual states. There was not until relatively recently a standing federal army. The point was to keep arms in the hands of individuals.

The Bill of Rights is a check on large centralized government. It's the whole point. Don't forget that these guys had just been through precisely such a revolution. There are some pretty striking quotes from Thomas Jefferson directly on point.

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by dpatru on Thursday June 14, 2012 @11:13AM (#4111668)
The second amendment is explicitly written to secure a right of the people against infringement by their government: the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Protection against foreign armies is already provided for in Article 1 (Congress has the power to fund the military) and Article 2 (the President is the Commander-in-chief of the military.)
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by DanielRibeiro on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @12:19PM (#4106732)
The "nothing to fear/nothing to hide" also goes against the Presumption of innocence[1], present in many countries' civil law.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presumption_of_innocence

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by andrewflnr on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @12:45PM (#4106907)
The bulk of your logic makes sense, besides depending on taking "privacy is an inalienable right" as a premise. However, on a practical level...

  "Because we're better than that"
In order to fight a war[0] from a "better than that" position, you have to have vastly greater power, enough to compensate for the hobbles you put on yourself to remain "better". Otherwise, whoever fights dirtiest wins. When people are trying to kill us, how do we make up for not listening to them, without letting people die?

[0] In a loose sense. Terrorists try to kill us, and the only way to stop them is with force. A lot of the same principles apply.

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by janardanyri on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:39PM (#4108602)
A group of terrorists lucked into taking down two big buildings and so we have to debate whether we can afford civil liberties? The premise should be self-evidently absurd.

If we'll kill thousands of Arabs to protect freedom, we shouldn't be so eager to walk away from it for the death of a few thousand Americans.

I would also suggest that abandoning principle for expediency can be hobbling in itself. Wars aren't entirely fought by robots just yet. "Power" isn't a column in an Excel spreadsheet.

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by dllthomas on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @12:53PM (#4106961)
The only way to stop existing terrorists may be to kill them. The things that go into stopping prospective terrorists from becoming actual terrorists are more complicated.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by JohannL on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @08:31PM (#4109223)
"Everybody's worried about stopping terrorism. Well, there's a really easy way: stop participating in it."

-- Noam Chomsky

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by theorique on Thursday June 14, 2012 @10:03AM (#4111365)
Somebody tell Al Qaeda. I'm sure they'll listen to a reasoned debate.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by khuey on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @01:20PM (#4107112)
But we do have vastly greater power. Terrorist groups definitely don't have a budget of 680 billion USD[0].

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_S...

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by dllthomas on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @01:31PM (#4107194)
While I agree with the point, raw budget comparisons are not a valid way to make it; terrorists also aren't defending such a big piece of land (and sea), and are more narrowly focused in scope as well.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by padraigm on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @03:09PM (#4107837)
The raw budget comparison is not the end of the United States' military superiority; the US has access to cruise missiles and aircraft targeting systems that allow them to put a precisely-measured dose of explosive through practically any window in the world at a few moments' notice. Meanwhile, the "terrorists" are strapping some fertilizer to a Nokia brick phone and laying it on the side of the road in the hopes that a truck will drive by so they can detonate it. The US so vastly out-matches the people it's fighting right now that they're having to write new strategic doctrine to be able to handle it. Are you really trying to make the argument that we don't have enough leeway to keep some principles in the process of defending ourselves?
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by dllthomas on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @04:07PM (#4108144)
Of course the raw budget comparison is not the end of the US's military superiority; I said I agreed with the parent's general point: that while additional constraints may make it harder to achieve tactical objectives, we don't have any trouble achieving tactical objectives.

My point was just that the metric being used was irrelevant to the comparison being made.

Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by andrewflnr on Thursday June 14, 2012 @02:30AM (#4110124)
In the intelligence battle, though, how much can we afford to cut ourselves off? A large budget is of little use, unless we can spend it on surveillance equipment...
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by hcurtiss on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @03:32PM (#4107951)
Liberty creates risk. Yes, the terr'ists may get a few of us from time to time. It's not, IMHO, worth giving up our civil liberties to prevent that.
Re:Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have 'Nothing to Hide' by strictfp on Thursday June 14, 2012 @02:18AM (#4110092)
> Do you want the terrorists to win?

The terrorists have won if we give up our freedoms in fear of them. That is their whole tactic.