News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by scott_w on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @11:07AM (#41057857)
How do you do that when the Russian military won't let you near the weapons?
Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by Retric on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @12:49PM (#41058994)
Ukraine had physical control of these weapons. They handed them over in 1994, 3 years after the fall of the USSR for assurances Russia would respect their borders.

More generally a handful of soldiers isn’t the full might of a countries military. Bribes, blockade until they run out of supplies, or just shoot them.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by s1artibartfast on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @04:27PM (#41061663)
Everything I read stated that Russian military was in possession of the weapons, but they were located within Ukraine. Perhaps bribery was an option, but Russia had the ability to destroy them at any time, either by scuttling them or bombing them.
Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by Retric on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @07:20PM (#41063238)
Operational control yes, but the assumption was these weapons where sitting in a friendly territory. Ukraine definitely had enough control for diplomacy to come into play. ~1,700 nuclear warheads spread across a large number of different sites is a nightmare to try and secure when the country was effectively falling apart.

As to bombing 130 nuclear silos with non nuclear ordnance is problematic and doesn’t destroy the enriched uranium which means building a bomb from the wreckage isn’t nearly as expensive as starting from scratch. None of this came into play because the Ukraine government was still reasonably friendly at the time.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by scott_w on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:12AM (#41066833)
> the assumption was these weapons where sitting in a friendly territory

You seem to be missing the key point that I've repeated twice already.

UKRAINE DID NOT WANT RUSSIAN TROOPS IN THEIR TERRITORY.

There was no path to Ukraine maintaining the nuclear weapons while also NOT having the Russian troops on Ukrainian land. The discussion of "oh, they can re-wire the weapons" would have trigged IMMEDIATE WAR with Russia. Ukraine DID NOT WANT TO DO THIS.

I really don't understand why you're bringing up any other information because what I've written is the start and the end of the discussion.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by Retric on Thursday July 25, 2024 @12:03PM (#41070233)
> no path

Clearly war was one option to remove Russian troops. Saying there’s no options, is a vast oversimplification.

Call up the troupes on the phone and say we’re unhappy about those ICBM’s in our territory where going to start artillery bombardment noon tomorrow and suggest you leave before then.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by s1artibartfast on Thursday July 25, 2024 @12:26PM (#41070507)
Apparently that path came with consequences that made it less attractive than giving it all up.
Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by Retric on Thursday July 25, 2024 @01:23PM (#41071121)
Many options were less attractive, but the government also had very close ties with Russia at the time so there was an impetus to find an excuse to hand them over.
Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by scott_w on Thursday July 25, 2024 @02:25PM (#41071746)
Yes, the option in that case was “get nuked into fucking oblivion by the Russians” and know the USA would not have stepped in. I’m sure the Ukrainian top brass spent a long time wargaming that one </sarcasm>

Please explain how instigating a war with Russia leads to less troops on Ukrainian land.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by Retric on Thursday July 25, 2024 @08:04PM (#41074727)
Leave we are going to start shelling that location tomorrow isn’t a declaration of war, it’s a threat. What happens afterwards can vary quite a bit, rather than your simplistic understanding of how the world works. Starting a war when the country was in the middle of a total economic collapse was hardly a viable option for Russia at the time.

There’s been 2 wars between Russia and Ukraine without any nukes involved. Nuclear bombardment of a country on your border isn’t such a great idea of a whole host of reasons.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by scott_w on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:59AM (#41076403)
What do you think Russia’s response to that would be?

“Leave us your nukes or we’ll take them by force.”

Talk me through the next steps.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by Retric on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:58AM (#41077306)
Timing is a big deal here the day after USSR dissolved likely would have gotten them to leave. Our nukes is an arbitrary viewpoint, it’s not like the USSR limited nuke production to inside Russia.

As things stabilized inside Russia it quickly became too late, but actually shelling the location of using an EOD team to ‘destroy’ the nukes puts a different spin on things.

Re:United States Discloses Nuclear Warhead Numbers; Restores... by scott_w on Friday July 26, 2024 @08:30AM (#41078061)
You’re living in a fantasy world if you really think this. We’d have seen Ukraine cease to exist by 1993. If Russia wasn’t in a state to fight conventionally, they’d have nuked Ukraine.

The USA would do nothing because why would they defend an antagonistic state trying to become a nuclear power?

If you think otherwise, you really aren’t living in the same reality as the rest of us.

How do I know this would have happened? Ukraine chose to give them back. They did the same calculation but, unlike you, they understand how things really work and what would really have happened.