Thx Amix. I was not aware of the site. Seems a very good resource, though its usability centered.
I would still like to see some discussion around the original post - with web emphasis.
Perhaps like: http://www.nngroup.com/reports/ecommerce/checkout.html
Well, again, that link is design oriented. I guess I'm looking for a similar article to what the original topic was about: "Science of _online_ shopping"
I think majority of their analysis is by looking and analyzing real e-commerce customers by video, hot maps etc. - i.e. they basically do the same thing Paco Underhill does (thought Paco is probably a lot more detailed in his approach).
Other than this, I think the safest bet is to trust the data, e.g. A/B testing. Being too smart without any testing could lead to fatal mistakes - Google has thousands of phd's and they still trust real user testing more than "opinions" (at least according to Peter Norvig :)).
Paco Underhill seems to use the same method, i.e. observing real customers and then drawing conclusions.