Re:Open Source in Europe: Facing the regulatory challenge
by mnau on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @08:01PM
(#41052333)
I really appriciate the efforts of Eclipse foundation and others.
The first version of CRA was devastating for open source. Thanks to their efforts, the adopted version has a lot of clauses for open source, it's survivable. Open-source stewards should be "subject to a light-touch and tailor-made regulatory regime", components are mostly exempt.
Re:Open Source in Europe: Facing the regulatory challenge
by protocolture on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @09:29PM
(#41052810)
Can someone summarize the impact on say, an open source project with no actual paid release?
Is this a case of, if anyone in europe compiles your software, and it doesnt meet standards, you are now a criminal? Or is the onus on europeans to install only certified software?
Obviously dependencies go pretty deep these days, is say Package B certifying for itself and Package A. Or is Package B assuming Package A will also provide its own certification?
Can you comprehensively fail the certification and have it revoked?
Re:Open Source in Europe: Facing the regulatory challenge
by bhjgjy on Thursday July 25, 2024 @11:34AM
(#41069877)
The regulatory landscape in Europe is posing new challenges for the open source community, especially with the Cyber Resilience Act (CRA). While the focus on security is welcomed, navigating these new requirements will be tough, particularly for smaller projects. The CRA's demands could significantly increase development costs and complicate compliance. It's essential for open source advocates to stay engaged and proactive in discussions to ensure the regulations are fair and practical. How do you think the community can best address these challenges?
The first version of CRA was devastating for open source. Thanks to their efforts, the adopted version has a lot of clauses for open source, it's survivable. Open-source stewards should be "subject to a light-touch and tailor-made regulatory regime", components are mostly exempt.
Is this a case of, if anyone in europe compiles your software, and it doesnt meet standards, you are now a criminal? Or is the onus on europeans to install only certified software?
Obviously dependencies go pretty deep these days, is say Package B certifying for itself and Package A. Or is Package B assuming Package A will also provide its own certification?
Can you comprehensively fail the certification and have it revoked?