Whilst I agree with your point, the problem is a quest (like "Ask HN: Does the password reset work for you?") would probably have sunk to the bottom without anyone seeing it.
Not a judgement on HN, but rather a judgement on human nature!
Re:
by delan-temp on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:30AM
(#4105057)
Something like that happened, actually; I did make a submission [1] like the kind you suggested and received almost no response.
Re:
by ricardobeat on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @08:18AM
(#4105455)
Is hackerne.ws an official alias for news.ycombinator.com? I'm a bit wary of logging in to two different sessions/domains.
Edit: I think some would probably view that as the appropriate response.
Or simpler, create a new account and test the password mailing function with it.
Re:
by delan-temp on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @05:53AM
(#4105112)
I did do this, in fact. My second last email describes how I created a new account and made sure that the associated email address was entered correctly, but still no email was received.
So the lesson learned here is, rather than write a blistering criticism of a free service, make sure you are right. A better way to handle it would be to have posted here a question asking others if password emailing worked for them or if it was just the OP. This would have done a bunch better job of determining if it was broken at the HN side or somewhere between there and one's mailboxes.