Re:Study predicts imminent irreversible planetary collapse
by nkurz on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @04:22AM
(#4104873)
I disagree with your note, but have resisted the urge to down vote it. McIntyre does not concede that the paper could "stand perfectly fine", rather allows that its conclusions may be correct result despite serious methodological and statistical flaws in the approach:
[T]he specific impact of an erroneous method on a practical data set is hard to predict. In our case, it does not mean that a given reconstruction is necessarily an “artifact” of red noise, since a biased procedure will produce a Stick from an actual Stick signal. (If the “signal” is a Stick, the biased procedure will typically enhance the Stick.) The problem is that a biased method can produce a Stick from red noise as well and therefore not much significance can be placed to a Stick obtained from a flawed method.
I agree that McIntyre's tone is ungracious, and fear it may be counterproductive, but I don't think that the Karoly's email was that gracious either. In particular, he did not thank anyone for pointing out a flaw, rather for "also identifying" it, moments after it had been coincidentally found by the original authors. Nowhere does he allow that the auditors provided any new information.
Rather than politely accepting this face saving maneuver (a commenter compared it to the polite fiction of not noticing that someone farted at a cocktail party) McIntyre impolitely, but in my opinion, accurately, calls out the lie and accuses him of failing to give proper credit. Here's the original in case anyone is interested in pursuing it themselves:
[T]he specific impact of an erroneous method on a practical data set is hard to predict. In our case, it does not mean that a given reconstruction is necessarily an “artifact” of red noise, since a biased procedure will produce a Stick from an actual Stick signal. (If the “signal” is a Stick, the biased procedure will typically enhance the Stick.) The problem is that a biased method can produce a Stick from red noise as well and therefore not much significance can be placed to a Stick obtained from a flawed method.
http://climateaudit.org/2012/06/10/more-on-screening-in-gerg...
I agree that McIntyre's tone is ungracious, and fear it may be counterproductive, but I don't think that the Karoly's email was that gracious either. In particular, he did not thank anyone for pointing out a flaw, rather for "also identifying" it, moments after it had been coincidentally found by the original authors. Nowhere does he allow that the auditors provided any new information.
Rather than politely accepting this face saving maneuver (a commenter compared it to the polite fiction of not noticing that someone farted at a cocktail party) McIntyre impolitely, but in my opinion, accurately, calls out the lie and accuses him of failing to give proper credit. Here's the original in case anyone is interested in pursuing it themselves:
http://climateaudit.org/2012/06/08/gergis-et-al-put-on-hold