News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study predicts imminent irreversible planetary collapse by InclinedPlane on Wednesday June 13, 2012 @03:29AM (#4104733)
Yes, I read the original, in its entirety.

As to peer-review, this was not published as either an "article" or "letter" (see: http://www.nature.com/nature/authors/gta/2a_Manuscript_forma...) but as a "review", which is more or less just a published essay. As such it falls under a much different peer review guideline.

Even so, peer review is no surety of fact, far from it, it's nothing more than a signoff that the authors have seemingly followed the basic forms of reproducible scientific investigations. However, in this case I think that Nature has let down its readers even in publishing this essay as a "review".

There is nothing that is not vague and generic in this essay. There is no model here, no theory. And no predictions nor falsifiability. It is not science in any sense and should not be treated as science. At best it is the shadowy outline of a future theory, at worst it is politics, mysticism, and superstition masquerading as science. And yes, reprinted in one of the most prestigious science journals of our times. That doesn't make it better, that makes it worse.

There are no comments on this comment yet.